Mama Maria's Pizzeria and Subs — Restaurant in Florida

August 22 2025 - First visit: takeout for 3.

Had some phone trouble or they were super busy?

My wife could not get through and got hung up on twice..... so I drove the 2 miles over. The front take out counter crew was very friendly and apologized for the issues. I ordered in the restaurant and waited.

My family came to South Philly in the mid-1800s and I grew up there for 45 years - LaSalle HS and Drexel U downtown. My at one time over 400 total cholesterol and my 185 CAC score is a testament to the cheesesteak experience I have had? (grimace) We have found (except for Gentiles who i heard is closing) not found anything close to a Philly Cheesesteak, not matter what the claims and "the experts" down in FL seem to feel they have eaten.

So we gave the Steak Bomb a try and also got a large plain cheese pizza as the reference standard. About $33 for them both, could not find a large plain cheese on the menu priced exactly but I think it was $19 which is good, and the Steak Bomb HOAGIE they call a sub. (the on-line Google menu is 2 years old and the prices are about 10% or more higher. ALSO there is a credit card "service" charge 4?% so be prepared.

The steak product was very good and nicely chopped and cooked. Not too crazy on the cheese and the onions and garnishes were appropriate. Very tasty! The problem with either matching or beating a Philly Cheesesteak come down to ONE THING after you get the meat, cheese, and onion down right.... its the Amoroso roll OR something like it? The roll here was nice but the outside had a thin "brownish" toasted crust like many "steak rolls" do and the interior "dough"/bread was sort of airy and a little stiff. An Amoroso is soft and the outside is just golden brown not toasted. Trying not to be too hard on them..... great effort and one of the closest in the area!!! 7/10

The large plain, I think was 16". Some allowance for my delivery distance from store to home should be made, but unlike some others the inside of the box was not all steamy and soggy... this has been our take out pizza curse down here in Florida. The sauce is okay with a little tanginess, the cheese seems high quality and "stretchy" and not stuffed with whey and fillers. The crust appeared high caliper but when we unpacked at home it was a little lip and soggy? maybe it got steamed in the car? Maybe it need a little more time??? The cheese pizza expert in my family was not a fan of this pizza. I thought it was better than most in the area. (Of note I had two slices left over and this pizza REALLY re-heats WELL!) 8/10

First impression, meaning there has to be a second or third as well, a future stop IN to get a fresh pie and also maybe some other steak varieties to...

Experience Authentic Italian Flavors at Mama Maria’s Pizzeria & Subs in Venice, FL

If you’re craving an unforgettable Italian dining experience, head straight to Mama Maria’s Pizzeria & Subs in Venice, FL. Located at 2085 Tamiami Trail South, this beloved local eatery is your gateway to the rich and tantalizing flavors of Italy, right in your neighborhood. At Mama Maria’s, every dish is a masterpiece. Their renowned hand-tossed pizzas, calzones, and subs are crafted to perfection. Picture biting into a crispy yet soft crust, topped with a perfectly balanced marinara sauce, high-quality cheese, and the freshest toppings. Whether you’re a traditional Margherita lover or eager to try the daring Steak Bomb calzone, Mama Maria’s promises a delightful culinary journey.

What truly sets Mama Maria’s apart is its exceptional service and cozy atmosphere. The friendly, attentive staff ensures that every visit feels special. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, expect a warm welcome and a delightful experience. The family-friendly, cozy ambiance at Mama Maria’s makes it ideal for any occasion. Be it a quick lunch, a casual dinner with friends, or a special celebration, the welcoming environment enhances the overall dining experience. Enjoy Mama Maria’s delicious offerings from the comfort of your home with their takeout and delivery options. With credit card acceptance and ample parking, convenience is guaranteed.

Visit Mama Maria’s Today!

Discover the best of Italian cuisine at Mama Maria’s Pizzeria & Subs. You’ll leave with a satisfied stomach and a smile on your face. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 8:30 PM, Mama Maria’s is ready to serve you the finest pizza and subs...

I wanted to give a special shout-out to Mama Maria's in Venice! Any true Floridian will tell you how difficult it is to find food after a hurricane and power outage.

I'd like to see people give them business during this time!!

I subscribe to Mama Maria's Pizzeria in Venice on social media (If you haven't, you should do so!!) They said they were open for lunch today! Got here and found they had a limited menu which is fine! They only take cash, but they are able to accommodate people who are looking for real food!!

I am VERY thankful to the wonderful people of Mama Maria's! They allowed us to stay and charge our devices as well as we have been without power! They're very kind and the best part, a local business!! The pizza slices were delicious (and I probably ate them in record time, LOL!!)

Thank you Mama Maria's for being open today! I ask that if they don't have food when you get here, again, limited menu, that we be kind to them! They're doing the best with the hand they've been dealt! To find a restaurant that's open, it's awesome!! 🙂

This is a tough time for all of us here, granted, but to see Mama Maria's Pizzeria in Venice open, it's truly wonderful and we very much appreciate it! They're a quality place for a great meal at a good price! We're so happy that we got to go here for lunch today!

SUPPORT LOCAL BUSINESSES!! They need our support more than anything right now!!

Thank you Mama Maria's Pizzeria! You are all awesome!! We will remember your kindness and support and I ask that we support their business...