That Guy's Pizza — Restaurant in Fountain Hills

So sad to see Redendo's go. The food is tolerable at That Guy's Pizza, but we had to wait 5 minutes while the cashier figured out how the register works and how to complete the phone order she had taken. Never asked us if we were carrying out or dining in, so they just assumed we were dining in. They looked baffled when we asked for to-go boxes after they brought our food out on a tray. I got all the way to the car and realized that they put the wrong toppings on our pizza. When I went in, I was informed that we had already had a conversation about it, that they were out of one topping and so decided to give me another which I had apparently asked for. This was news to me. I have no recollection of such a conversation ever taking place. The incompetence of this place will cause me to wait for the business to change...

Wow! I'm still thinking about the meatball sandwich I had at That Guy's Pizza in Fountain Hills, AZ. It's not just a good meatball sub; it's the best I've ever had, hands down.

The meatballs were perfectly seasoned and cooked, tender and full of flavor. But what truly sets this sandwich apart is the combination of everything: the rich, savory meat sauce, the gooey, melted mozzarella cheese, and the bread. The bread was incredible—toasted just enough to be crispy on the outside, but soft and chewy on the inside, holding everything together perfectly without getting soggy.

This isn't just a sandwich; it's an experience. I can't recommend it enough. If you're in Fountain Hills and looking for a truly fantastic meal, you absolutely MUST TRY the meatball sandwich at That Guy's Pizza. You won't be...

We stopped in and had some very delicious pizza. Ordering a medium Pizza thinking it was 9.99 and and got one topping the total was 14 bucks... after receiving the pizza turned around and saw a sign on the window a large pizza with 2 toppings 11.99. When I asked about this discrepancy they just went oh... sorry. I definitely would have ordered the large pizza had I understood what it was all about. After eating our small pizza at the table... I actually went back and ordered a large 2 topping pizza for 11.99 to go and I mentioned politely once again about the confusion of the pricing and they just looked at me like... huh? So the pizza is great but watch their trickery in their pricing I felt it was deceptive and I was pretty insulted when they didn't even offer to give me a discount on my...