Paesello's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Goshen

Average at best. Not the cheesiest pizza, like Bruno's use to make. If you want a flavorful pizza consider Enzo's instead. If average is what you want consider cicis or little Caesar's, you'll end up paying a lot less for average.

Wow, they really can't take a little review. "After thoroughly investigating, we were unable to find any record of serving you. " So, should I provide a receipt of me going there? It's only my personal review, no reason to get hostile.

I thought about giving you a second chance, but not after reading your B.S. about not serving me. I will never eat there and advise others to not go there. Take the time to properly read what I wrote about Bruno's. Never did I state you were...

Finally ordered from here after 20 years. Ordered 2 pasta dinners. If your not a heavy eater one dinner can easily feed two. The round bread included was delicious the best I have ever had for take out. The side salad was large for a side and well made with notch above dressings. The meatballs are very good and obviously house made. I liked the baked mostaccioli but my wife wasnt a gan of the hard boiled egg pieces in it along with the thin sliced ham and pepperoni. I thought it gave more protein to a carb laden dish. The place is small but very clean and neat. Will order again when its...

Spent $62 on a pizza and some stuffed bread sticks. I should have realized what was going on since the bottom of the box was still scorching hot when I got it out of the car when we got home to Dunlap (maybe 10 mins away tops).

We get home, open the box and it looks great! Take out a slice and it's burned on the bottom pretty good. Every single piece in the box was burned. If you can get past the burned taste, it's good pizza... but being our first experience I can't see returning considering the price. There's no excuse for a whole burned pizza when you drop that kind of...