JT's Pizza & Pub - Grandview Heights — Restaurant in Grandview Heights

There are pizzas, and then there’s JT’s Pizza—a place that doesn’t just serve a meal, it delivers a moment. Tucked unassumingly into the Columbus dining scene, JT’s is crafting some of the most exceptional pies I’ve tasted not just in the city, but anywhere.

From the first bite, it's clear: this isn’t your average pizza. The crust is a revelation—crisp on the outside, yet beautifully airy inside, like it took a cue from the finest sourdoughs. It’s the kind of crust that earns silence around the table, followed by a collective “Wow.”

But JT’s isn’t just riding on dough alone. Their 12-hour sauce is pure alchemy. Simmered to perfection, it’s deeply savory with just the right kiss of sweetness and acidity—an ideal partner to the charred, delicate base. It’s a sauce that’s been cared for, loved, and it shows in every spoonful spread across the pie.

And then—the sausage. Hand-pulled, rustic, and profoundly flavorful, it’s the kind of topping that feels both old-world and freshly inventive. Juicy, spiced just right, and generously scattered—this sausage deserves its own standing ovation.

As for the service? Let’s just say JT’s knows hospitality. Jennifer guided our table like a seasoned host at a dinner party—warm, attentive, and effortlessly genuine. And then Joe, the owner himself, took the time to introduce himself to Shawn at our table. That single gesture turned a great meal into a memorable experience. JT’s doesn’t feel like a restaurant—it feels like a neighborhood you’ve belonged to for years.

Without hesitation, JT’s Pizza has entered my personal top three pizzas—not just in Columbus, but anywhere. For those who consider pizza a passion, this is a must. For those who don’t yet, JT’s might just convert you.

Columbus, take note: JT’s Pizza is...

Normally, I’m not one to write reviews, but this experience was simply too remarkable to keep to myself. From the moment I walked in, Jennifer’s attentive and personable service set the tone for the evening. Then came the pizza—absolutely phenomenal—crafted with a perfect balance of flavor, texture, and presentation. And Joe’s genuine hospitality elevated the entire atmosphere, making me feel more like a welcomed guest than just another customer.

I’ll admit, I arrived skeptical, expecting yet another overhyped, overpriced “trendy” pizza spot. I couldn’t have been more wrong. The prices were surprisingly reasonable, and my choice to order water instead of a beer didn’t alter the warm, welcoming service one bit. This wasn’t just a restaurant; it was a place where quality and care clearly take priority.

Without hesitation, I’d rank this pizza in my personal top three for taste, quality, portion size, and value. An evening here isn’t just dinner—it’s an experience worth savoring. Thank you for a truly NYCE...

I decided to try JT's for the first time after hearing of their success in 97.1, the Fan's pizza march madness bracket tournament, making it all the way to the finals. I decided to give them a try and I am so happy I did. I have found my favorite new pizza place. Put it this way, I am not a sausage on pizza guy and love their sausage...fennel flavor packed! Love the crunch on the bottom bake of the crust. I have tried it now 4 times and gotten something different each time! I love they have monthly specials (pizza and apps) and in trying the wings (bone in) they were made fresh to order and tasted it.. Puts wings at places like Donatos to shame... more than double the size! I used to order donatos all the time because it was easy and safe, yet becoming more and more expensive and less and less quality OR quantity for the cash.. Since I tried JT's, I haven't been back to Donato's. I am sure they are wondering where I am... I don't plan to be back.. Jt's is a go to pizza place and I can't wait to try more items...