Brother's Pizza on Whitehorse — Restaurant in Hamilton Township

I just tried to post my story and I guess it was for some reason it won't let me post it so I guess I can't go into detail about how bad they treated me as their customer today so I'll keep it short I called them asked them for help and I spend my money here all the time they sent me to three different people in that little pizza place and nobody knew who the pizza maker was until I got to the third person who was the pizza maker I told him all my story and then when I talk to the pizza maker and they didn't know what pizza making was about he refused to make me Cheesesteak rolls that were tiny even though I wanted to pay for them for individuals to have them because he wanted to give me strombolis for 14.00 a piece so I had to drive out of my way to go to another pizza place to get the mini Cheesesteak rolls and it was not $14 a piece so I went out of my way to get what I needed and know I'm never going there again and I'm going to tell everybody I know not to go there Angelo is sold it and he sold it to the wrong people because they don't care about the customers they didn't want to make cheese steak rolls with the dough and The Cheesesteak cuz they said they couldn't do it well and I told him how to make them and he couldn't do it so what do they know they were ignorant and I'll never go there again and they lost money just me and my close friends spend $150 to $200 a week there and then all the people that I've sent there to go there regularly I'm going to tell him all to stop going they did this and there's no free pizza in the world that will bring me back I'm not cheap lol see I'm trying to make a joke out of it cuz it's funny so stay away from Brothers Pizza by Kmart White Horse Tavern I'm sorry came lights gone or don't ask them to do anything special cuz they can't do it not even if you pay for it That's What I Call non-customer relations and...

February 6, 2020 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I’m new to Hamilton New Jersey and I read the reviews about the best pizza in Hamilton and almost everyone say brother’s pizza on route 33 is the best!!! Well I’m telling you that’s not true!!! Brothers pizza in Whitehorse ave, foleys supermarket plaza is the best pizza in Hamilton. I taste both pizzas and route 33 brothers is awful. Brothers on Whitehorse is delicious crust is awesome tasty and sauce is good. Just good pizza. Try it

UDATE: January 11, 2021 ⭐️👎🏾

Not happy at all 1st the person on the phone was very rude!!!! 2nd not wear mask correctly under his nose!! Should have took pictures. 3rd They sold me old pizza. The driest, hardest pizza I ever had🤬 I did not finished it. Should have returned it. I know people have bad days, but I felt I wasn’t treated right from the phone call to when I entered the place and what was sold to me. I take my business...

Not really sure what happened to this place. Used to be our go to. New owners, maybe?? Ordered a total of 5 things and FOUR out of the five were wrong. Ordered 2 buffalo chicken cheesesteaks and SPECIFICALLY mentioned allergies to blue cheese, so confirmed several times AND had the girl read the order back to me to make sure. 20 minutes later go to pick up, only 1 cheesesteak was made and it of course, had blue cheese on it. Sat for an additional 20 minutes for them to make 1 single cheesesteak. Meanwhile, the rest of the food got cold. Ordered cheese fries, no cheese in sight. Their calzone is half the size it used to be, and their pepperoni pizza looked like someone dropped it and put it back in the box. It's a shame, we really used to love this place. Will be going elsewhere...