Johnny's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Hanover Township

So this is an addendum to my original review from our first experience with Johnnys. Ever since the first delivery it has now become our exclusive go to for take out/delivery. We have ordered one pie but have also ordered 5 pies and many other menu items in one order for family parties and the quantity of items and a busy Friday or Saturday night does not change the results. From pizza to apps, wraps, salads, pasta and hot sandwiches literally every thing we have had from there has been absolutely delicious. The pizza always has a thin crispy crust which lets the toppings be the center of attention instead of a bunch of dough. They are consistent with the quality and taste and the customer service couldn’t be nicer! They also accommodate some of my interesting remix requests of menu items. Tonight we had a special request baked ziti pie with vodka sauce and it was fantastic. We also love the chicken parm pizza with vodka sauce just to name a few. Johnnys food has become part of the family. Thank you!

This was our First time getting food from Johnny’s. We order Italian at least once a month for poker night and once a week usually for Friday dinner. They had great prices and friendly customer service over the phone when I placed the order. Everything was delicious, still hot when delivered and the order was correct. Great experience all around!...

We're relatively new to town and have been excited to try as many different local restaurants as possible. We've tried many of the local pizza joints and finally got a chance to try Johnny's (conveniently located 5 minutes away). We ordered a half cheese/half Hawaiian pie, a half white/half Margherita pie, garlic knots, and garlic bread with cheese. The plain pie was pretty good and seemed to be made with high quality ingredients, but we couldn't believe how high the prices were. We paid $28.89 for one of the pies, which was simply NOT worth it for the skimpy amount of toppings. I attached the receipt to show the cost breakdown. I'd recommend Johnny's if you're just getting a plain pie, but not for any type of pizza beyond that. We're not planning on returning after our experience. We'll stick to the other high quality and delicious pizza joints in town that are much more reasonably priced and generous...

Don’t like hearing complaints because a business charges you a fee to use a credit card. I wish every restaurant (especially cheap joints like pizza and burgers) charged customers for using credit cards. If you want to pay the banks for nothing then YOU pay the banks. I’d rather have lower menu prices and pay cash. If you were smart, you’d agitate against the BANKS! It’s the banks who are bilking all of us — the restaurants and the customers. So stop being dumb and charging everything — even pizza! You’re a patsy if you do that. Carry more cash. Stop driving up the price of everything and letting the banks get away with...