Nicholas Creamery — Restaurant in Long Branch

Found this creamery after a long day at the beach and I was so happy we decided to choose this one out of the few we found...

First of all, the place was packed and that was the first sign it was a good choice. The staff was super friendly and understanding. We were a big group on top of the huge crowd that was there, and that can be challenging sometimes but it was as smooth as it could've gone.

Almost all of us decided to get medium ice cream on a waffle cone... the cones are made at the store and those were the BEST cones I have had. You can tell they were fresh, and they were crispy but with some softness and thicker than usual, just the cones are business potential.

I had cherry goat cheese and cookies and cream. The cookies and cream was as good as it could be, creamy, with tonsss of cookies... the cherry goat cheese flavor tasted just like cheesecake and was soooo good!!! Like 4 of us ended up choosing it after they gave us some to taste.

Loved the creamery and will definitely be back if I'm ever around the area!! Totally...

Service was helpful and respectful, but not the best first impression when both ice creams I tasted (GIMB and Peanutbutterpalooza) where frostbitten and icy. For small batch, handcrafted it didn’t taste much better than the mid-level ice cream at grocery stores, and those at least have more mix ins as advertised. I found the peanut butter flavor left both a greasy and grainy texture in my mouth, while the GIMB was a very basic,...

The ice cream is always delicious, however the issue is the inconsistency in serving sizes. Some of their staff really go out of their way to ensure you don’t get your money’s worth, especially when it comes to the soft serve. For nearly $7 they could at least give a little more ice cream as opposed to barely filling the cup and skimping on...