Papa Johns Pizza — Restaurant in Lower Paxton Township

Love this place. They always treat me well and have great pizza. You get what you pay for. A little more expensive it very good quality.In the realm of fast-food pizza, Papa John's has consistently set itself apart with a commitment to quality that justifies every penny of the price. With numerous pizza chains vying for supremacy, a 3.8-star rating across 176 reviews speaks to a performance that garners both admiration and loyalty among its clientele.

It's always a culinary delight to discover a place that provides not just food but an experience that leaves a lasting impression, and Papa John's seems to do just that. As a local guide with a discerning palate and extensive reviewing experience, when one notes that Papa John's pizza is a beloved spot that 'always treats me well,' it underscores the chain's dedication to customer service, which is as integral to dining as the food itself.

Papa John's mantra of "better ingredients, better pizza" isn't merely a slogan but a philosophy that resonates with each slice. It is a testament to their use of fresh, quality ingredients that elevates their pizzas from the mediocre to the sublime. While they might be a tad pricier compared to their competitors, it is evident that the investment yields dividends in the form of a superior pizza that doesn't cut corners.

The pizza crust, often a contentious point among pizza aficionados, holds its own with a delightful balance of fluffiness and crunch. Topped with robust tomato sauce that strikes a harmonious chord of tanginess and sweetness, it sets the stage for a variety of toppings that are always fresh, plentiful, and distributed with a generous hand.

What makes Papa John's worthy of commendation is their consistency. To maintain a standard of quality across numerous franchises is no small feat, yet Papa John's manages to do so, ensuring that the delectable experience is one you can count on, whether you're at your local haunt or across the country.

In conclusion, Papa John's provides a gastronomic experience that warrants its slightly higher price point. The warmth with which regulars are treated, coupled with the undeniably superior taste of their pizzas, assures that every meal is not just sustenance, but an enjoyable event. It's the commitment to maintaining these standards that cements Papa John's status as a front-runner in the fast-food...

Absolutely the worst Papa Johns. Ordered a Shaq-a-Roni pizza with mushrooms. Simple order. I guess it was not simple enough for them. Go get the pizza. Bring it home and no mushrooms. So I take it back and tell them they forgot the mushrooms. I get a very lame "sorry". The manager then says we'll make another one for you. Like she was doing me a favor. Finally pizza is done. They forgot to give me the pepper and garlic sauce. Take the pizza home and NO CHEESE!! Call them and tell them and get another lame sorry. Asked for corporate number and by my suprise the manager did not no the number. Believe me, I'm not making this up. They did not even offer to reimburse or make another one. Will NEVER order from this...

So listen, I have a bad habit of leaving my sunroof open. Sometimes, it rains 3 inches of water in my car. But sometimes, I find myself at Papa John’s on Linglestown Rd locked out of my car, staring helplessly at my keys sitting on my seat… but I see my open sunroof! Not only did the employees greet me immediately upon entering, but they didn’t skip a beat to come out when I asked if anyone could possibly help me out. They all came out. one held my pizzas, one helped boost me up and throw me head first into my open sunroof to retrieve my keys, and one was there for moral support. They saved my butt and not every establishment would care to help, so KUDOS to the three of them on 8/27/25 at...