NY Times Square Pizza — Restaurant in Lutz

I went to this informal pizzeria after driving from brandon with my 2 children to take care of some business at my air bnb on that side of town. I was originally going to take the food to go back home when my 2 children stated they were hungry, I decided we would just eat there. I told the order taker that when I got there. She KNEW when they started my food that I had changed my mind about taking it to go. Either way, there still would've been tons of pizza left and it still would've needed to get boxed to go since I was also going to feed my husband and oldest child at home. I asked her for some cups so we could pour soda from the 2 liter I bought THERE into it so we could enjoy while eating. She informed me that I could not have a foam cup, but the plastic rewashable cups. I said ok. Food finally came out and we proceeded to eat there, cleaned up our own table and upon leaving the rude order taker decides to tell me " next time let us know you're eating in so we can serve you properly." Mind you, a man that walked in while we were eating ordered 2 pizza slices and a drink (dined in) in which she gave him a foam cup in which he served himself at the fountain machine and when the slices were ready, he walked up and got his own food from the counter. Just an example as to what she meant by being served "properly." I initially asked her for some pamphlets with the menu so I can furnish for my air bnb guests and she handed me 5 copies. I WILL NOT BE RETURNING NOR WILL I SUGGEST MY GUESTS TO ORDER FROM THEM! Lost my business and potentially MANY MORE! Also, beware of the ice. The ice had black particles in...

I have been a loyal customer of this establishment since 2010, and I can confidently say that it offers an exceptional dining experience. From the moment you step through the door, the owner and her staff create a welcoming and professional atmosphere. Their attentiveness and courteousness are truly commendable.

One aspect that sets this place apart is the outstanding quality of their food. The menu selection is truly remarkable, offering a wide variety of options to suit any palate. I have never had a disappointing meal during my 13 years of patronage. In particular, their authentic and delicious New York-style pizza stands out, with a sauce that is perfectly balanced. I highly recommend trying their delectable garlic knots as well, as they are my personal favorite.

Despite living in Wesley Chapel, my family and I are more than willing to travel here just to enjoy dinner at this exceptional establishment. The combination of authentic New York pizza, phenomenal customer service, reasonable prices, and a family-friendly environment make it the ideal destination for an enjoyable dining experience.

If you are in search of a place that offers genuine NY pizza, impeccable customer service, competitive prices, and a great atmosphere for your family, I wholeheartedly recommend this...

Usually not in the mood for pizza, but when I am , I must go for some good NY style pizza . (Not a fan of extra thick dough). Did a quick google search & stumbled upon this small pizza shop. Pretty easy location to find, and it also has a very convenient parking lot which is always a plus.

Anyways, as soon as I went in I felt like I was in a pizza shop at my hometown(NY). The wall painting is cute & the place overall is well put together . The staff was super friendly & welcoming.

Now to the most important part: I ordered the white cheese pizza and it was delicious. The dough thickness was just right . The best part is that the pizza wasn't greasy. I literally ate 4 slices and still didn't feel disgusted with myself, pretty cool. Not heavy at all. ( pizza slice is completely foldable like NY pizza, thumbs up for that)

I would go back whenever I'm having a craving for pizza . Prices are decent and download the slice...