Benny Scarpetta's — Restaurant in Lynchburg

This was the worst service I’ve had in years. I’m a college student that COMPLETELY understands when things get stressful but after being there for half an hour, I asked about our missing slice of pizza 10 minutes after our order came out and they said they still needed to make it. 15 more minutes went by so I asked again. I saw them open the oven to reveal a REALLY burnt piece of pizza. I’m not sure if they know I saw it but they turned back to me to tell me it’ll be another 10 minutes. 15 more minutes go by so I asked a third time and this time, they FORGOT TO MAKE IT HAHAHA. They said it would be another 10 minutes. At this point, my family finished eating 35 minutes ago and workers are mad at ME for some reason but the last thing I want is to continue waiting. I asked if I can just have a refund and leave and they said there’s nothing they can do. Like huh? What? What do you mean? One of the girls stormed from the back and angrily wrote me a gift certificate for $6.50 but I don’t want it I’m never coming back. Benny’s stole $6.50 from me and...

Stopped in today (12-1-2019)for lunch with my daughter. Road in front is currently under construction but there is a convenient parking deck just across the street. A colorful and interesting facility. Eclectic decor .It looks like it was once an old apartment building, with a grand staircase in the back. You can sign you your name and draw on the wall if you like. There is a real, hugh honest to goodness, genuine,old fashioned functional pinball machine in the back. Brought back a lot of memories to play it! I'd go back just for the pinball. We had pizza, and the slices are as big as your head! It comes from a 28 inch pizza!They were promptly served piping hot.Very tasty! Reasonable price for what you get. There is a prize if you can eat an entire pizza yourself in less than 60 minutes. Only a few have accomplished this feat! The restrooms are clean and festooned with old comic strips wallpaper above steel plating. I definitely recommend and look forward...

New to the area, most of our kitchenware was still in boxes when we decided to stop in for a few slices at Benny's. My partner had shared that a full pie was 28" across. -double blink- Twice the width of our previous go-to pizzeria. We each ordered one slice for dine-in and two slices for the next day's breakfast and lunch. Thinking ahead! ;)

Each slice was centered across two paper plates, which was later useful to scoop the warmed up triangles out of our oven when we realized we also hadn't yet found our oven mitts. We tried the broccoli and cheese , 3 pigs, pepperoni, and garlic mushroom - all were delicious. The blue moon mango wheat complemented this carby goodness and we appreciated the complimentary cups of seasonings set...