Mr. Bentley's Homemade Ice Cream — Restaurant in Marco Island

I went there with my girls. I ordered one of the special sundaes. After scooping up the ice cream she told me they didn’t have the toppings that were in the sundae. It was very overpriced for a bowl of vanilla ice cream and a cookie wafer. Very disappointed. I wish she would have told me they didn’t have the ingredients before she started scooping it out. $14 is too much for a bowl of vanilla ice cream. My girls liked their ice cream, but it’s too overpriced, even for...

We went with high expectations of a new ice cream shop. Cute little store but that is where the pleasantness ended. Ice cream was tasty but very overpriced with tiny portions (1 waffle cone and 1 small cup was just under $14), the size of the scoop is standard to anyone's kitchen at home. Huge soft serve machine in the store but not working, and the gal at the counter said it had never worked. I wish them well. I think it's going to be a...

Stopped in last year after they opened and they definitely have only improved since then! Great ice cream and the portion sizes increased significantly. The ice cream is the best I’ve had on the island with a great amount of unique and tasty choices! Great staff working in the store and they happily answered all our questions. Additionally, I love that they used fake ice cream to show you how much ice cream you would get for each size...