Tito’s Pizza — Restaurant in Martinsburg

SUMMARY: Tito's is a Mexican (read: Latin American) restaurant that also makes decent pizza and great wings.

I've been to Tito's many times over the past year and have never had an issue. I prefer Tito's pizza, my wife prefers Anthony's, but we both agree that Tito's is THE place for buffalo wings.

We've only ever done take-out. I can affirm that the dining room is dark as other reviewers have mentioned. I can't speak to any service beyond counter-service, which has always been great. The staff is friendly and seems genuinely excited to sell what they see as a quality product.

I see negative reviews on the pasta, and I can't speak to those either way. I've never tried it. What I can speak to is the unexpected delight that is the "Mexican Originals" portion of the menu.

Never mind that some of the items are actually Salvadoran, Colombian, or Dominican. You're not reading this review for a geography lesson (side note: food anthropology is FASCINATING). You're here to know whether the food is worth your cash. It is.

I've tried the pupusas, special burrito, and fried yuca. It's been a minute, but I remember thinking, "I should get this again." Particularly the pupusas, which come with pickled carrots & cabbage.

The calzone and stromboli are also solid choices. They were on par with any I've had...

My experience with a delivery order yesterday was incredibly disappointing and inconvenient. As I was sick and exhausted I decided to place an order for delivery I received the wrong order I received these nasty hard tameles instead of my yuca order I called them and the guy I spoke to asked me if I didn’t like tameles why didn’t I keep them for one what I ordered costs more money then the tameles and they were all nasty and hard and it’s just not what I ordered. So basically he tells me that I would have to bring in the tameles to get my order remade so I told them at that point I just want everything refunded they refused to refund me even if I brought EVERYTHING I ordered back plus I’m 5-7 minutes away they could easily remade my order and brought it to me but instead I had to drive late all sick to return the tameles and wait another 15 minutes to get my order remade… all they offered me was a free soda like that’s just crazy too me this isn’t the first time this has happened either but food here isn’t even that good to be honest so I won’t be ordering from...

OK before I start this review, I just want you to know I am not bashing this place at all. I'm just giving you my 100% honest review. First of I want to say that I used to love going here.. But since they got their name changed to Tito's pizza, they have not been the same. I think it has to do with the new management, because the pizza does not taste the same. But what really kills me, is that their cheesesteak does not taste like a cheesecake anymore…. What I mean by that is, it is so dry (from the meat to the bread) it was so hard to digest. They used to have one of the best cheesesteaks in this area area, but now it does not complete. My opinion is that they need to go back to being a pizza/sub (Italian style restaurant).. They are doing too much trying to incorporate Spanish food into their menu. By the way, Their Spanish food is not good at all, I give it a 1 out of 10. But I hope your experience is better than mine if you decide to stop here and eat. Because I used to eat here every once...