HTML SitemapExplore
logo
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants

New York Pizzeria — Restaurant in Maryland

Name
New York Pizzeria
Description
Local pizzeria chain serving pies, pasta, subs & salads in a relaxed atmosphere.
Nearby attractions
Carroll County Public Library - Eldersburg Branch
6400 W Hemlock Dr, Sykesville, MD 21784
Nearby restaurants
McDonald's
1722 Liberty Rd, Sykesville, MD 21784, United States
Roy Rogers
6400 Ridge Rd, Eldersburg, MD 21784
Chipotle Mexican Grill
6400F Ridge Rd, Sykesville, MD 21784
Genova's To Go
1834 Liberty Rd, Eldersburg, MD 21784
MOD Pizza
6400 Ridge Rd Building B, Suite 10, Sykesville, MD 21784, United States
Mo's Cafe
1912 Liberty Rd Unit 8, Sykesville, MD 21784, United States
New Win Long Chinese Restaurant
1912 Liberty Rd, Eldersburg, MD 21784
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
6400B Ridge Rd, Eldersburg, MD 21784
Jersey Mike's Subs
6400 Ridge Rd Suite B1, Sykesville, MD 21784
Wheatgrains Deli
1912 Liberty Rd Unit 6, Eldersburg, MD 21784
Nearby hotels
Related posts
Keywords
New York Pizzeria tourism.New York Pizzeria hotels.New York Pizzeria bed and breakfast. flights to New York Pizzeria.New York Pizzeria attractions.New York Pizzeria restaurants.New York Pizzeria travel.New York Pizzeria travel guide.New York Pizzeria travel blog.New York Pizzeria pictures.New York Pizzeria photos.New York Pizzeria travel tips.New York Pizzeria maps.New York Pizzeria things to do.
New York Pizzeria things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
New York Pizzeria
United StatesMarylandNew York Pizzeria

Basic Info

New York Pizzeria

1720 Liberty Rd c, Sykesville, MD 21784
4.4(238)
order
order
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

Local pizzeria chain serving pies, pasta, subs & salads in a relaxed atmosphere.

attractions: Carroll County Public Library - Eldersburg Branch, restaurants: McDonald's, Roy Rogers, Chipotle Mexican Grill, Genova's To Go, MOD Pizza, Mo's Cafe, New Win Long Chinese Restaurant, Tropical Smoothie Cafe, Jersey Mike's Subs, Wheatgrains Deli
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(410) 552-4400
Website
newyork-pizzeria.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Maryland
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Maryland
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Maryland
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
dish
Calamari Dorati
dish
Greek Salad
dish
Meat Sauce
dish
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
dish
Meat Sauce
dish
Bolognese
dish
Shrimp & Crab Diavolo
dish
Shrimp Scampi
dish
Calzone

Reviews

Nearby attractions of New York Pizzeria

Carroll County Public Library - Eldersburg Branch

Carroll County Public Library - Eldersburg Branch

Carroll County Public Library - Eldersburg Branch

4.8

(63)

Open 24 hours
Click for details

Things to do nearby

Dining in the Dark: A Unique Blindfolded Experience
Dining in the Dark: A Unique Blindfolded Experience
Sun, Dec 21 • 5:30 PM
10221 Wincopin Cir, Columbia, 21044
View details
Candlelight: Christmas Carols on Strings
Candlelight: Christmas Carols on Strings
Sat, Dec 20 • 6:30 PM
610 Park Ave, Baltimore, 21201
View details
The Elf Bar: A Christmas Pop-Up Experience - Baltimore
The Elf Bar: A Christmas Pop-Up Experience - Baltimore
Sun, Dec 14 • 6:00 PM
523 York Rd, Towson, 21204
View details

Nearby restaurants of New York Pizzeria

McDonald's

Roy Rogers

Chipotle Mexican Grill

Genova's To Go

MOD Pizza

Mo's Cafe

New Win Long Chinese Restaurant

Tropical Smoothie Cafe

Jersey Mike's Subs

Wheatgrains Deli

McDonald's

McDonald's

3.5

(604)

Click for details
Roy Rogers

Roy Rogers

3.6

(206)

Click for details
Chipotle Mexican Grill

Chipotle Mexican Grill

4.0

(242)

Click for details
Genova's To Go

Genova's To Go

4.2

(96)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.
logo

Posts

Steve GrimesSteve Grimes
16 Jul 24 the jovial gentleman that showed us to the table may have been the owner. Another wonderful dinner. Our waitress (who also served the bar) was so attentive, she had great timing. mango habenero and bay wings were excellent as ususal. Our salads were very, very good, - as usual? The quality of the food and the service is incredible. The owner has engineered a really fantastic restaurant. 25 June 24 what a fantastic staff! Bartender asked us for drink orders before we sat down. Our waitress awesome s was very attentive and so sweet. I liked the godungjang wings but didn’t like the Nashville they didn’t have any dimensional flavor. I expected smoke, mustard, or molasses. Both types of crab soup were very good. The cream of crab soup is very rich my wife felt full after only a few spoons. 23 April 24 We really enjoyed dinner tonight. The new dining room is fantastic, the owner blended the bar area and new space by providing the same brick, flooring and black wainscot. Our waitress McKenna was a sweetheart. She was efficient and accomodating. We left her a big tip and will be glad to see her again. As usual the mango habenero and bay wings were great! Perfectly prepared and hot from the kitchen. My wife's reuben was top notch, she said that was as good as reuben's in her two favorite restaurants. The happy hour cabernet and merlot were disappointing, we will look at other reds next time. Another great meal. I had the southern chicken salad and loved it. My wife’s Caesar was just ok, she’ll order the other salads next time. The wings were super good. This is the best j&p! What a fantastic place! Nicely decorated dining room with tables and booths all well maintained and clean. Loved the vindaloo wings and thought that the mango, mild, bay were also excellent. My wife thinks that their pizza is the best in all surrounding counties, she makes a 20 minute drive to have lunch here. Dinner options include chicken, veal, and steak as well as pasta dishes. They offer a few wines and sweeten the deal by offering happy hour Monday through Friday
Christy CzajkowskiChristy Czajkowski
I’m sorry, I don’t like leaving bad reviews but I have given this place one too many chances. The first time, I dined in and ordered a deep dish style special pizza and regular pepperoni pizza with my parents who have eaten here previously. When the pizza came out, it was literally overflowing with cheese. Like, I have never seen a literal river of liquid cheese flowing off of a slice like that before. And at first we thought, great, more cheese! But that’s basically all it was and sent our whole party to the bathroom all night, despite taking lactaid prior. My parents said that all the times they’d had pizza here before, it’d NEVER been that cheesy before. We wound up throwing all of the leftovers away. This most recent time, ordering carry-out, I opted for a safer bet- an Italian Cold Cut. To my dismay, the cold cut was toasted (??? It’s a COLD CUT.) and had literally nothing on it besides meat and cheese. HUH?! Like no mayo, no oil or vinegar, no seasoning, no lettuce, tomato, or onion. Just meat and cheese. At the end of a long day of work, this was a HUGE punch to the gut. Will literally never be eating here again. So sorry to say that because I’m all about supporting local business but Y’ALL. This is just a slap in the face to a real Italian or New York style deli.
Michael MorganMichael Morgan
Friday was our first time ordering this resturant. I ordered pickup online at 5:27 and due to me driving right past the location I got there after 6pm. My wife's shrimp salad wrap was ready , but the pizza wasn't ready. Which was understandable, because the place was really busy. I saw a guy eating wings at a table and immediately wished I ordered some, because the guy looked like he was enjoying them. I left around 615 to drive back to owings mills. The pizza was still warm. My son gave it a 8.5 out of 10 on his pizza scale. We will definitely order from here again. We may dine in instead.
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Maryland

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

16 Jul 24 the jovial gentleman that showed us to the table may have been the owner. Another wonderful dinner. Our waitress (who also served the bar) was so attentive, she had great timing. mango habenero and bay wings were excellent as ususal. Our salads were very, very good, - as usual? The quality of the food and the service is incredible. The owner has engineered a really fantastic restaurant. 25 June 24 what a fantastic staff! Bartender asked us for drink orders before we sat down. Our waitress awesome s was very attentive and so sweet. I liked the godungjang wings but didn’t like the Nashville they didn’t have any dimensional flavor. I expected smoke, mustard, or molasses. Both types of crab soup were very good. The cream of crab soup is very rich my wife felt full after only a few spoons. 23 April 24 We really enjoyed dinner tonight. The new dining room is fantastic, the owner blended the bar area and new space by providing the same brick, flooring and black wainscot. Our waitress McKenna was a sweetheart. She was efficient and accomodating. We left her a big tip and will be glad to see her again. As usual the mango habenero and bay wings were great! Perfectly prepared and hot from the kitchen. My wife's reuben was top notch, she said that was as good as reuben's in her two favorite restaurants. The happy hour cabernet and merlot were disappointing, we will look at other reds next time. Another great meal. I had the southern chicken salad and loved it. My wife’s Caesar was just ok, she’ll order the other salads next time. The wings were super good. This is the best j&p! What a fantastic place! Nicely decorated dining room with tables and booths all well maintained and clean. Loved the vindaloo wings and thought that the mango, mild, bay were also excellent. My wife thinks that their pizza is the best in all surrounding counties, she makes a 20 minute drive to have lunch here. Dinner options include chicken, veal, and steak as well as pasta dishes. They offer a few wines and sweeten the deal by offering happy hour Monday through Friday
Steve Grimes

Steve Grimes

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Maryland

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
I’m sorry, I don’t like leaving bad reviews but I have given this place one too many chances. The first time, I dined in and ordered a deep dish style special pizza and regular pepperoni pizza with my parents who have eaten here previously. When the pizza came out, it was literally overflowing with cheese. Like, I have never seen a literal river of liquid cheese flowing off of a slice like that before. And at first we thought, great, more cheese! But that’s basically all it was and sent our whole party to the bathroom all night, despite taking lactaid prior. My parents said that all the times they’d had pizza here before, it’d NEVER been that cheesy before. We wound up throwing all of the leftovers away. This most recent time, ordering carry-out, I opted for a safer bet- an Italian Cold Cut. To my dismay, the cold cut was toasted (??? It’s a COLD CUT.) and had literally nothing on it besides meat and cheese. HUH?! Like no mayo, no oil or vinegar, no seasoning, no lettuce, tomato, or onion. Just meat and cheese. At the end of a long day of work, this was a HUGE punch to the gut. Will literally never be eating here again. So sorry to say that because I’m all about supporting local business but Y’ALL. This is just a slap in the face to a real Italian or New York style deli.
Christy Czajkowski

Christy Czajkowski

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Maryland

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Friday was our first time ordering this resturant. I ordered pickup online at 5:27 and due to me driving right past the location I got there after 6pm. My wife's shrimp salad wrap was ready , but the pizza wasn't ready. Which was understandable, because the place was really busy. I saw a guy eating wings at a table and immediately wished I ordered some, because the guy looked like he was enjoying them. I left around 615 to drive back to owings mills. The pizza was still warm. My son gave it a 8.5 out of 10 on his pizza scale. We will definitely order from here again. We may dine in instead.
Michael Morgan

Michael Morgan

See more posts
See more posts

Reviews of New York Pizzeria

4.4
(238)
avatar
5.0
1y

16 Jul 24 the jovial gentleman that showed us to the table may have been the owner. Another wonderful dinner. Our waitress (who also served the bar) was so attentive, she had great timing.

mango habenero and bay wings were excellent as ususal. Our salads were very, very good, - as usual?

The quality of the food and the service is incredible. The owner has engineered a really fantastic restaurant.

25 June 24 what a fantastic staff! Bartender asked us for drink orders before we sat down. Our waitress awesome s was very attentive and so sweet.

I liked the godungjang wings but didn’t like the Nashville they didn’t have any dimensional flavor. I expected smoke, mustard, or molasses.

Both types of crab soup were very good. The cream of crab soup is very rich my wife felt full after only a few spoons.

23 April 24 We really enjoyed dinner tonight. The new dining room is fantastic, the owner blended the bar area and new space by providing the same brick, flooring and black wainscot.

Our waitress McKenna was a sweetheart. She was efficient and accomodating. We left her a big tip and will be glad to see her again.

As usual the mango habenero and bay wings were great! Perfectly prepared and hot from the kitchen. My wife's reuben was top notch, she said that was as good as reuben's in her two favorite restaurants.

The happy hour cabernet and merlot were disappointing, we will look at other reds next time.

Another great meal. I had the southern chicken salad and loved it. My wife’s Caesar was just ok, she’ll order the other salads next time. The wings were super good. This is the best j&p!

What a fantastic place! Nicely decorated dining room with tables and booths all well maintained and clean. Loved the vindaloo wings and thought that the mango, mild, bay were also excellent. My wife thinks that their pizza is the best in all surrounding counties, she makes a 20 minute drive to have lunch here.

Dinner options include chicken, veal, and steak as well as pasta dishes. They offer a few wines and sweeten the deal by offering happy hour Monday...

   Read more
avatar
5.0
3y

Sorry in advance for the book but they deserve more then a 4 word statement ! Just to start off, Their food is amazing!! I live 45 mins away and they were able to cook my pizza just short of completion so my family can enjoy it hot out of the oven for dinner which i didnt expect to get it done medium well lol ive always had bad luck reheating just a littleto long and burning it, hopefullythis will prevent that and still taste as close to freshas possible. Everyone is extremely friendly weather your new as i was or a everyday customer, yes everyday because if i was to be in the area everyday i could never get tired of the food and even though I can't say that any of the customers were local and a regular but i in no way got that feeling you get when you know they know your not from around here 😄. I haven't had it in years and happened to be passing by leaving a job and had to cut across the lanes to make a quick turn in when I noticed their sign, as I was waiting I over heard the manager talking with a customer about making up some sauce with different ingredients/flavors nothing from the menu just out of generosity and may not be a big deal but I thought that was the best thing I've seen or heard of a restaurant owner doing for their customers in a long time, the locals definitely have a great Italian/pizza restaurant in the area and wish I was closer to it myself. The Mt. Airy location was my first visit, and I did some work there replacing the HVAC years back and happy to come across this one. Definitely stop in and get a bite to eat completely worth it!!!...

   Read more
avatar
4.0
4y

New York J & P Pizza sells a variety of foods. I’ve eaten here often. Our family often purchase an extra large cheese pizza, (3) salads and (3) orders of chicken wings. The pizza was cheesy, hot and delish! The slices were folding slices. The combination of sauce to cheese to spice ration was outstanding. The crust is something I never eat, but I ate theirs. It was crispy and chewy. It was delicious. I really enjoy the chicken wings from this location. They are not heavy handed on the seasoning when it comes to flavored chicken wings and french fries. You can always ask for more seasoning as they have been gracious to provide anything extra. The wings are large. They can be purchased in amounts of (6), (12), and (18). They provided the freshest carrots and celery sticks with your choice of dressing/dipping sauces. I have also had the salads. They are fresh deliciousness in a container. Greek salad and shrimp salad salad are what I often go towards. They salads are more than a single portion. The salad containers are equivalent to a large clear clamp clam shell container as well as large aluminum container with the clear lids. Each time I’ve ordered they have repeated my order to ensure accuracy of the order as my order details were exact each time. I do recommend this establishment for a nice...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next