Papa's Pizza 2 — Restaurant in Mayagüez

Hands down the best pizza I've had. IMO, it's the standard all pizza places in Puerto Rico should aspire to. Owner Wilhelm Rodríguez has perfected his trade and has trained very well his employees to deliver said standard on every pizza they dish out. I've had the opportunity to go and eat multiple times and the taste and freshness is there every single time. Last time I was there, I enjoyed very much his Detroit Style Pizza. His New York style is on another level. It's crisp and flavorful. Overall, Papa's Pizza is the best. Do try it. You...

The good first: nice and cozy place, strategically located, and clean. Next, the not-so-good: pizza is average and not worth the price. They may benefit from being the only decent pizza near the plaza. And lastly, the bad: I ordered from the menu in Google Maps, but it was outdated. When I went to the store to pick it up, there was no record of the call or the order. But worse, the employees and manager did not even care to solve or compensate for the mistake on their side (not having a record of my...

They’re not open until 8 and will tell you they’re closed at 7:30 unless they are just against serving people who aren’t locals, which would be silly given they’re attached to a building with a hotel. Having worked my first job at a pizza place, I know for a fact it only takes about 10 minutes to make and bake a pizza unless they just don’t have an actual pizza oven, which is the only reason I considered arriving within 30 minutes of their...