Pop's Frozen Custard — Restaurant in Menomonee Falls

Looking for a sweet frozen treat that will keep you cool during the hot summer months? Look no further than Pop's Frozen Custard! This local custard shop offers a wide array of delicious flavors that will satisfy any sweet tooth.

From classic vanilla and chocolate to seasonal favorites like pumpkin and peppermint, Pop's Frozen Custard has something for everyone.

But it's not just the variety of flavors that makes Pop's Frozen Custard a standout. The quality of the custard is truly exceptional - creamy, rich, and perfectly textured. This is a testament to the fact that all of their custard is made fresh on site, using only the finest ingredients.

And if you're in the mood for something a bit more indulgent, be sure to check out Pop's selection of toppings and mix-ins. Whether you prefer candy, nuts, or fresh fruit, there's something for everyone here.

One thing that really sets Pop's Frozen Custard apart is the friendly and welcoming staff. From the moment you walk in the door, you're greeted with a smile and helpful advice on the best flavors and toppings to try. This makes every trip to Pop's feel like a special occasion.

The only reason I'm not giving Pop's Frozen Custard a five-star review is because, at times, the lines can get quite long during peak hours. But even then, the wait is always worth it for the delicious, high-quality custard that awaits.

Overall, if you're looking for a sweet and satisfying treat in town, Pop's Frozen Custard should definitely be at the top of your list. With delicious flavors, high-quality ingredients, and a friendly staff, it's no wonder that this place is a local favorite. Check it out today!

🌐 Facebook: diamante/lara/realtor 🏘️ Community Member & Real Estate Services 🔑 Buy /...

I have always been a fan of Pops, but today I was very disappointed in their service. My friend is lactose intolerant, and she ordered a hamburger with no butter or cheese and received a regular cheeseburger. That’s fine, mistakes happen sometimes. So we told one of the younger ladies in the front and explained that she’s lactose intolerant and politely asked them to remake the burger. The girl just rolled her eyes, didn’t say anything and seemed extremely annoyed. That’s terrible customer service. Not even an apology was extended. Then they remade the burger and handed us another burger with cheese. The first time they messed up we were understanding. But the SECOND TIME?!?! My friend had to again re-explain that she’s lactose intolerant and can’t have cheese. The girl seemed even more annoyed like we were really inconveniencing her. It’s just sad. It’s not like my friend just doesn’t like cheese. There’s a reason. And we explained it. She can’t have it. And even if she just didn’t like cheese it doesn’t matter! The customer asked for an order and received it wrong twice. No apologies extended either time. Just attitude. Terrible customer service. Not sure I can go back. It’s a food allergy for...

My family has been going to Pop’s for years since we moved to the Falls. It’s always been good, with good service and prices that were decent, but not great. I thought the slightly higher prices were justified because it’s a small business - the kind of place my family and I like to support.

Tonight, I stopped in because I was craving custard after I had dinner at home. I was SHOCKED to see that a “Snow Storm” was $8.99! A Google review from just three weeks ago had a picture of the menu, showing the same item at $6.79. Of course, inflation touches everything. But this just feels exploitative.

Because I was already there and don’t want to spend any more time, I reluctantly ordered my custard, but, disappointingly, that will be the last time I stop at Pop’s. There are a lot of other options. Maybe other folks can spend that kind of money at a place like Pop’s- they were busy tonight - but it won’t be me.

The service was still good, food and atmosphere are okay. But the value just isn’t what it used to be, so...