Hole Lot of Bagels — Restaurant in Middletown Township

I have been coming to this Hole Lot of Bagels store for years! It’s my weekly Saturday trip ! They are truly amazing!! They have the best bagels too!! The bagels are always fresh and I buy a dozen every week and they are part of my son’s breakfast everyday! The sandwiches are made with a lot of love and filled with a ton of meat for a great price!! The eggs, cheese, and bacon always freshly made!! The whole lot of grain is delicious!! It’s my absolute favorite! Along with all with cream cheese options!! They have the most amazing staff who always greet you with a smile and just treat you like family! When my son was in the hospital at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, his one request was that we Hole Lot of bagels!! Also, I have catered from them multiple times and have always received RAVE reviews!! Lisa is amazing to work with and helps with everything to do with catering! Most recently I’ve catered for a large group of events and the experience was incredible. Everyone loved their bagels muffins and assorted cream cheese!! She knows what you event needs! They truly are family business that once you go one time you will never want to go anywhere else!! They are that part of Middletown business...

Original review - This is our first time actually getting from hole lot of bagels, I ordered a lightly toasted onion bagel with scallion cream cheese. This bagel was delicious. Nothing was left I ate the crumbs! The people serving today were immensely nice, wonderful and professional, and the food was just spectacular. You guys at hole lot of bagels have two brand new customers!

Update - 08/02/2025

Today felt like night and day from the above review. We asked for the bagels to be lightly toasted, they were nearly burnt. They put on perhaps 1/5th of the cream cheese they did the last time. Barely anything. If in the future things are better I will change my score back.

Update update - 08/09/2025

I am very happy to say, that today is the day where they did good by me once more. Nothing extra special or out of the way, just done the way they did it the first time and everything was amazing. I happily give back the few...

Price dose not match quality. They can't justify charging that price for what I got. I ordered an everything bagle with tuna. Bagels was delicious and fresh but tuna was dry and bland. 2nd for almost 8 bucks it comes with a side salad which consists of 2 tablespoons of mayo an one table spoon of coleslaw. I could not finish it. And they have giant pickles on display but the ones they give with the 8 dollar sandwiches is a sliver, a tiny sliver. 1/6th of the size compared to the pickles on display. Then when it was time to go, I was talking to a coworker of mine in the resturant and they put our food in the same bag? Why? We did not order together. We did not pay together? So it seems a bit racist. I will not return and do not recommend to anyone who does not go there out of convenience of...