Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream — Restaurant in Millcreek Township

Ex employee here, pay was only $8 an hour with tips for 10 hours a week, owners were two-faced people, Denise especially was a pretty rude and aggressive woman. Owners take a share of tips, one day they left with all the tips from the tip jar when they left early so I lost wages I did not get back that day. Took a month for them to bring in the proper paperwork for direct deposit and my W-4 forms all while paying me with personal checks from their business account. Lot of shady stuff going on there. They make their employees lie to customers. If they're handed a tip that's told it's theirs only, they have to pretend to pocket it and then put it in the tip jar after the customer leaves which the owner gets part of. On my second to last shift I pocketed $5 that a lady specifically wanted me to keep. I got in trouble with Jenida for it where it ended with her yelling at me, threatening to call the cops, calling me a thief, calling the owners claiming I was stealing their money, and physically assaulting me. Had to call the cops on them, turned out she already has a previous criminal record and got in a fight in prison. Very unprofessional. Tried to lie to the cops falsely claiming I was stealing from the register drawer but refused to show footage (cause it doesn't exist). Not worth the overpriced okay quality food. Small business doesn't always mean...

They have Homemade Dough, Sauce, and Import their own Banana Peppers from Italy. They're Very Sweet Banana Peppers, not "Hot", whatsoever. We had ordered their Extra Large Pizza. They called it, "The P". A Pizza w/32 piece's, vs. 16 piece's. They give you a starting point with Pepperoni and Cheese. We added Bacon, Extra Cheese and Banana Peppers. I've never known anyone in Erie, PA., to make "Detroit Style", Pizza's before. They actually make Detroit Style Pizza in all the Pizza's they create. "Detroit Style" is a combination of 2 Styles of Pizza: 1. Deep Dish Chicago Style Pizza. 2. Thin Extremely Large Crust Brooklyn Style Pizza. I knew of and made, one other Style: Thick Extremely Large Crust Brooklyn White Style Pizza. My friend's from College would go to my parents house, yo eat authentic Sicilian Food. They learned these "Styles", and suggested these "Styles of Pizza" to a local pizza shoppe. They actually added their own version to that Style of Pizza. Very few people back in the 1980's, knew how to make White Pizza Style the...

We had a 10/10 experience at Presque Isle Pizza and Connie’s ice cream both during our visit and afterwards. The food and ice cream were AMAZING, highly recommend the turtle and black raspberry. The friendliness of everyone there was truly unmatched. My daughter accidentally left her cup(we were traveling back home from Pittsburgh and this was her Steelers souvenir cup, from her very first game) we were about 45 minutes into our drive home after stopping for pizza and ice cream when we realized it was left behind. My husband called thinking no way are they going to mail it home to us but Dave saved the day and shipped the cup out the next day! It arrived today and we’re so grateful. We’re from WNY but we’ll...