Cold Spoons Gelato — Restaurant in Milwaukee

Because I saw a good number of great reviews on this place, I decided to give it a try. I walked into the place with it being empty, but customer service was stellar; I was greeted by the ice cream server right away. She was more than happy to serve us the multiple samples we asked for. I had the Salted Caramel, which was creamy, but average. Something you can get at Target prepackaged. My boyfriend got Blue Moon, which he didn't sample. It was grainy, watery, and not at all your traditional Madison Babcock Hall Blue Moon. It tasted more like cotton candy and bubblegum than anything. Lastly, they didn't have a variety of cones. They ones they did have were stale. Despite the quality of the gelato, the server was accommodating, sweet, and had a great attitude...

Very nice product and great presentation, i liked the gelato. The service was good, but that’s where it ends. The serving sizes are baby sized, the small is almost the same size as large and i DONOT.like the star cups. The chest freezer on display had NO pints to buy and take home. which was very disappointing considering the small portion sizes for the price paid. The interior had very minimalistic decorations and the seats had a tear. Considering the area it was appropriate (ish) but could have a bit much more character. Definetly some room for improvement, considering the small portion sizes cold spoons wouldnt be my first choice of a place to stop

(FYI THE LARGE IS SMALLER THAN A SNACK...

Great gelato and sorbet. Extremely small servings for how expensive it is. I recommend that you get the PINT over anything, economically it's your best bet You can get the LARGE which is literally 1 decent scoop for $7.25 or something or a whole pint for $9!!!!!!! Pink grapefruit is the best flavor and chocolate thai chili. Their hours aren't great but it is what it is. Every time I go there, it's absolutely dead inside. The staff are always great too. They may not know whats in every flavor but they're always patient as you try different flavor samples. All in all it's good but expensive. And some flavors taste similar. But I recommend the place...