Fratelli's Pizza — Restaurant in Moultrie

😱 if I could give this place negative stars I would. Went the other day. While the place is clean and the service was ok, the food is HORRIBLE!! I got the meatballs sub, wife got the cheesesteak sub with no ranch or mushrooms. We even joked with the kid behind the counter that we grew up in the area of the U.S. that is famous for these items and had been craving good copies of them. Now nothing is going to taste EXACTLY like something else necessarily, but I’ve been in the South for over 40 years and have had countless “copies” that have come deliciously close or better. Not so here. First of all the fountain drinks were mostly out. Sweet tea was full but needed more sugar ( ok personal), and tasted 4 days old. When we ordered we also asked about fries or onion rings to go with the steak sub and were told they didn’t have them on the menu. Weird, but ok. When the subs arrived, the bread was so toasted it bordered burnt. The meatballs on the sub tasted ok, but there was little to no sauce and zero flavor. The steak sub had one strip of green pepper and no onions, and the green pepper was raw. You are supposed to cook the peppers and onions WITH the meat. We are still looking for the cheese! The steak sub also had no flavor. Wife likes ketchup on her steak sub and since there was none on the table, I got up to ask for some at the counter and was told they didn’t have any, nor salt and pepper. Not even those little rip open packs 😳. We ate some of our subs and packed up the rest to take home to the dog. It should have been a red flag for us when he wouldn’t eat my wife’s food. Yep, you guessed it. About 4 hours later she started throwing up like a fire hydrant. While we can’t PROVE it was the steak sub that did it, suffice it to say WE won’t be back, and suggest you...

One of the best pizza places Moultrie has to offer! I called in an order and was told it would be ready in 15-20 minutes, and it was hot and ready when I got there! When I arrived I asked if I could add on an extra slice of pizza and a sub, and the staff were very accommodating and polite. multiple staff made sure that I was tended to, and everything was boxed nicely and handled with care.

The inside of the place is very clean, and you can see how clean the kitchen is from the counter which is always good sign. I ordered a single slice of cheese as a taste tester, some garlic knots, and a large margarita pizza. My family absolutely loved the flavor of the margarita, but mentioned that it could use some sauce. As for the single cheese, it definitely blew the other shops out of the water! It was a crispy and crackly crust that wasn’t too thick, a nutty and flavorful cheese, and a sauce that’s not too acidic or overly sweet! The slices here reminds me of what you can get in New York, and it will be our family’s go-to place for the foreseeable future!

I spent ~$52 with tip($5) for one large margarita pizza, one slice of cheese pizza, a 12” buffalo chicken sub, and two orders of garlic knots. The portions were large, and they didn’t skimp out on toppings for either the pizza or the sub!

Side note: they have a huge dough mixer in the kitchen, so they have fresh dough, which means no frozen...

My order was ready on time and the food was great. The staff were all friendly and inviting. They variety of toppings offered was exceptional. I do believe I saw gluten free options too, so perfect if you have a loved one with dietary restrictions. I would recommend...