Benny Palmetto's, Pizza — Restaurant in Mount Pleasant

Absolutely horrible pizza!! I don't know if they just stop caring after 11 PM (?) but we're so disappointed. Friday night, found this place, was so hopeful for some late night cheesy slices to hit the spot. Unfortunately, it's literally cardboard with the thinnest layer of cheese on top. I took 2 bites and couldn't even finish one slice despite being starving! It was so insanely dry - overcooked cardboard crust. Couldn't finish a bite without a bottle of water to help wash it down. My girlfriend and I literally went home, threw it away and made dollar Ramen, which was worlds better. I'm genuinely, and I mean genuinely, so confused at all the good reviews. Did we just come at a bad time or are these other folks reviewing this paid off? No idea but some of the worst pizza I've had in many years and I'm not picky at all! So easy to please. I literally couldn't swallow a bite it was just dry cardboard. No sauce and the thinnest layer of cheese on top of an overcooked, dry piece of cardboard. I literally took the pizza apart out of curiosity and there was no pizza sauce! It's literally a dry, overcooked cardboard crust with a millimeter thin covering of cheese and no sauce. I'm telling you, I dissected this pizza looking for any sauce at all and did not find any. Again, it was a millimeter thin layer of cheese, with no sauce whatsoever between the cheese and the cardboard crust. Absolutely disgusting. Literally inedible. I tried dunking it in as much ranch as I could so I could at least get some calories in my system as I was sooo hungry, but that couldn't even save it. I couldn't choke down more than 2 bites. I'm in disbelief that a pizza place like this actually exists and somehow gets good reviews. Blown away. I feel like I'm in the twilight zone reading these reviews talking about how good the pizza is? The worst part is, my girlfriend and I had had a few drinks and would've been the easiest customers on the planet to please! If they had served me a microwaved leftover slice of Little Caesar's I would've been more satisfied. At least Little Caesar’s puts sauce on their pizza! I would take theirs over this literally any day, it was absolutely TERRIBLE. I genuinely would bet money that the good reviews are from friends of the owner. I want my $20 back. I feel like I was pranked/genuinely feel like I was robbed of my money. Again, if they had just microwaved a leftover half slice of Domino's they left in the fridge from 2 nights ago, I would've felt better about that $20 I spent. Avoid at all costs, I promise you I'm doing...

Calling all pizza enthusiasts and daredevil appetites! If you’re on a quest for a larger-than-life pizza experience, then Bennys Pizza is your holy grail, complete with a mouthwatering twist. Brace yourselves for the colossal 28-inch pizza that’ll make even Godzilla’s jaws drop!

Picture this: You walk into Bennys Pizza, and your eyes widen as you witness the epic creation before you. It’s like a saucy, cheesy universe on a mission to satisfy your wildest cravings. But let’s talk about the taste, shall we? The flavors on this pizza are like a symphony of deliciousness, orchestrated by the culinary maestros at Bennys. The crust is perfectly crispy on the outside, while maintaining that pillowy softness on the inside, as if it had discovered the secret to achieving world peace.

Now, let’s address the elephant in the room (or should I say, the dinosaur?): the 28-inch diameter. This pizza is so huge that it might as well come with its own zip code. It could probably double as a personal trampoline, or a portable shield against any rogue vegetables approaching your plate. Forget about “slices” – you’ll be dealing with full-fledged pizza continents that would put the mapmakers to shame.

But here’s the fun part: tackling this behemoth of a pizza requires a strategy. You could channel your inner lumberjack and go for the classic slice-and-conquer method. Or, you could recruit an entire squad of pizza enthusiasts to help you devour it. Just imagine the look on their faces when they witness the sheer glory of Bennys Pizza! You might even make it to the legends of pizza folklore.

So, if you’re ready to embark on a culinary adventure of epic proportions, Bennys Pizza is waiting to welcome you with open dough. It’s where gastronomy meets acrobatics, and where flavor reigns supreme. Go ahead, take a slice (or ten) of this larger-than-life pizza wonderland, and join the league of brave pizza conquerors. Cheers to Bennys, where every bite is a delicious step towards pizza...

I never give reviews but my experience here was so bad I felt I needed to leave one. I went to eat here during vacation. Took my family. Ordered 5 pieces of pizza and 5 drinks, two of which were the $1 PBR's.

The kids grab their drinks and they bring me the 2 PBR's. The PBR's were room temperature. My wife brings them back up and they explain the PBR's were just put in the fridge and they didn't have any cold ones. We say no big deal and they put them back in the cooler for us. We were going to wait for them to cool down. So I end up ordering a different kind of beer and my wife gets a glass of wine to drink while the PBR's are cooling off

Then they call our names for our pizza order. I go to grab it and it is clearly burnt. I said something to the employee who was handing me the pizza order and he lies to me and tells me that the bottom is not really burnt. He tells me that is just the way their pizza is because of the oven and the "screen" they use.

I say ok. Bring it to the table and tell my wife and kids that employee told me that is just the way their pizza is cooked. We try to eat it and it is so overcooked that it is ridiculous. Then I notice the pizza the family next to us is eating and it was cooked perfect and not black on the bottom.

So I go back up and point that fact our to the same employee and he acts stupid and tried to act like he doesn't know what the I'm talking about. And I said look man the pizza burnt. He finally does what he should have done in the first place and offers to cook us new slices or give us a refund. I was so frustrated that the guy had given me the run around I asked for the refund. So get this... he shorts me $7 on the refund. At that point I just had enough and wanted to get out of there. So we left, hungry and short changed.

Any way, the pizza that wasn't burnt looked good. I would avoid this place. Really, really...