Foggy Nantucket - Foggy's Puck Cafe — Restaurant in Nantucket

I stopped by looking for the bakery that used to be here. At first I was worried because BBQ and bakery didn't go together in my mind. However, I'm glad Foggy Bakery is there now! Their breakfast bakery stuff is really fantastic. I got a sample selection including a sticky bun, foggy bun, cinnamon bun, chocolate croissant, and a little chocolate cheesecake treat.

The sticky bun and Foggy bun were amazingly good. They are probably the best bakery items on the island right now. Really Fantastic. The chocolate croissant and the cinnamon bun were very good. I haven't eaten any of the cheesecake thing yet.

I would have included more pictures but my family ate everything but the cheesecake before I could write my review.

I didn't try the BBQ food or the breakfast burritos because I was on a bakery morning run for the family however I'll be coming back next year when...

I feel like I must be missing something that all these other reviewers are talking about. Maybe under new management? Maybe a bad night? We found the pizza to be nearly inedible. We got a small meatball and small BBQ chicken pizza for take-out at a cost of $48.50. I understand island prices but this pizza had me wondering if we would have been better off heading to S&S frozen section and saving $30. The “dough” did indeed taste frozen and had that cardboard consistency of Red Baron or similar. Sauce was flavorless and cheese had no pull, definitely not freshly shredded. The lady at the counter was very friendly, but it wasn’t enough to overlook the pizza. Maybe the deep dish is better, but I won’t be...

Best experience of my life. I will forever remember the kind lady at Foggy’s pizza who hand delivered my cheese pizza in the midst of a hurricane. It’s a story I’ve told my children and will tell my grandchildren. It started with my pizza order. It just happened that the delivery services would not work that day for my pizza, and I couldn’t drive to pick up my pizza because a lady had boxed my car in. The precious angel that worked at Foggy’s understood my problem and decided out of the kindness of her heart to drive my pizza out to me. She didn’t have to do this, but she did. I haven’t even tasted the pizza yet, but the worker still...