Old Harbor View — Restaurant in New Shoreham

⭐ 1/5 – Worst Seafood Experience Ever!

This place is a complete rip-off! The prices are outrageously high, and for what you pay, you get almost NOTHING. I spent a ridiculous amount of money and walked out with barely enough food to feed one person. The portions are tiny, and it feels like they’re charging luxury prices for bargain-bin quality.

The staff doesn’t seem to care either – no explanations about the pricing, no effort to make things right. For the money I spent, I could have gone to a nice restaurant and had an actual meal.

Save your money and go literally anywhere else. This place is nothing but overpriced...

The cashier asked us if we wanted fries or onion rings with our order—insinuating they come with our entree. To our surprise it was an extra $8 for a side of fries and $10 for onion rings. Incredibly overpriced for mid food. The tiny Lobster roll was just one tiny lobster tail on a bun with shredded lettuce—for around $35 ($43 with fries). Three small chicken tenders with onion rings comes to about $20. Don’t forget the mandatory 18% tip. For a grand total of $70–party of 2 and we didn’t even order drinks. I know that business is tough and prices are skyrocketing everywhere, but they’re taking advantage. Go...

I ordered a coffee milkshake and got a milkshake that tasted like vanilla. I told the guy at the counter that my coffee milkshake tasted like vanilla.He went to correct it a second time and it still tasted like vanilla. I went back a third time to let them know and again it tasted like vanilla. As you can tell in the photo that the milkshake is white and not the coffee color that a coffee milkshake is. The service of this place is not good. I couldn’t understand the workers when I returned it a third time as they were speaking another language but from their expressions you could tell they...