Broadway Joe's Pizza — Restaurant in New York

I miss the days of eating really good pizza in Manhattan, like Ciro's, which used to be on Chambers, etc...it's been a long time since I've had that 'taste' - REAL pizza, not the 'fake 'n bake' you get from more recent pizza joints in NY. One day, on my way home to CT, I wandered into Broadway Joe's in the Bronx...it is truly legit, as it used to be, not over-done, back to basics, the real deal...keep in mind that, no matter where you have pizza, 100% of the population will not agree entirely on a single place, but if you want to taste history, try Broadway Joe's...I've eaten pizza at hundreds of joints in NY over the last 33 years...today, most follow a template that is ridiculous...it is hard to find this natural flavor that is truly missed. YOU be...

I’m from western Massachusetts and I went to NYC for a weekend trip. My friend and I had heard that New York has the best pizza, and I couldn’t have been more excited, since pizza is one of my favorite foods. I got a couple of slices of original pepperoni pizza. I am not exaggerating when I say that this pizza is the most delicious pizza I’ve ever had in my LIFE. (That is 22 years of pizza I might add.) I had stopped at 6 different places for pizza that weekend, in NYC and the Bronx. We even took one more stop back to this place on the drive back home because we knew we would never have pizza this good back home. 10/10 recommend, you HAVE to visit Broadway Joe’s Pizza. You will...

Sorry to do this to you Joe’s but your place stank today. Yes, it literally smelled bad. Ignored it and ordered a slice. The service I received made me feel like I bothered them, they preferred serving people of their own race first. The slice was also subpar and disappointing. It was also salty despite not having much sauce, something I thought difficult to do. I go around tasting slices of pizza here n there. Not countering the reviews you’ve gotten purposely, it just wasn’t anything similar in my experience. School pizza tastes better. Maybe another day would’ve been better but I won’t be coming back here. Nice...