Casa Margaritas Restaurant & Bar — Restaurant in New York

I have been going to Casa margaritas for about 4 years now and I truly love it. I moved to Elmont from Suffolk and I needed a good local spot for drinks and food. I was tired of the generic franchises that I have been going to Since my early twenties they are overrated and all are due for renovations and a menu upgrade (Fridays, Applebees ect.) So the hunt was on for a good local spot. I found casa margaritas on google. My first day I went with my friend Jen (who also loves casa margaritas) we had drinks some food and actually left and went to Gordos down the block to try it out. We ended up leaving Gordos after 1 drink and went back to casa margaritas. The food is BOMB 💣 my favorite dishes are the bandeja tipica which is the National dish of Colombia and the fish filet with shrimp that comes in a delicious creamy sauce. The drinks are BOMB 💣 my favorite margarita is the Spicy Tamarindo with Tajin on the rim on the rocks. The vibes are high the service is spectacular. The team is very attentive from the moment you enter the establishment until you leave. Food is fresh, hot and comes out pretty fast in my opinion. The prices are very reasonable for the high quality, great tasting food and portions you are receiving. If you come across Casa Margaritas I encourage you to go you wont regret it😁 birthdays are also very nice. I haven’t had one there yet but I’ve seen sooo many there and its awesome 🥳. Im deff doing a birthday 🎈 dinner at Casa Margaritas this year. I’ve also brought just about every friend here and they LOVE Casa Margaritas as well. Im a regular I go at least 1-2 times a week sometimes even 3-4 times a week in the summers. They also have a great variety and diverse playlist. I’ve had many drinks many dishes all are spectacular 🤩 Keep up the...

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Casa Margaritas, and I must say, it was an exceptional experience! The moment we walked in, we were warmly welcomed by the owner, Juan, who set the tone for a fantastic evening. Our server, Santiago, was attentive, knowledgeable, and friendly, making sure we had everything we needed throughout our meal.

The food was simply delicious! We started with the tostones con guacamole, which were crispy and flavorful, with a side of creamy guacamole that was perfectly seasoned. The quesadillas de pollo were tender and juicy, with a rich, savory flavor that had us both raving. And the pollo empanizado? Crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, and full of flavor.

But the real star of the show was the margaritas. Made with fresh ingredients and a generous pour, they were the perfect accompaniment to our meal. We left feeling full, happy, and already planning our next visit.

Overall, I highly recommend Casa Margaritas for its warm atmosphere, exceptional service, and mouth-watering food. The whole staff made us feel like family, and we can't wait to come back and try more of their...

Stay home ! I ordered the Arroz Mixito con Pollo, The chicken was like 10 days old and was hard and dried out , the vegetable's were frozen peas and carrots and not cooked . My Husband ordered steak quesadilla and again NOT steak but shredded beef and had a truly funky flavor and inedible. The drinks were ok nothing spectacular. Your money is best spent elsewhere. It will last like Atomic wings and that Mexican place before it, 6 months to a year. In response to the owners response , if when my husband had to get up to ask for the check after no one coming back to the table to ask if we needed anything or how was the food, The check came and My husbands plate was barely touched and all I ate was the salad No one asked why the plates were still full. I wanted to tell the waitress to take the food off the bill but my husband said to chalk it up to experience. Our bill was 61.90 and the lack of caring spoke volumes. And now 2 days later the owner has no response as to how they advertised a STEAK quesadilla on the menu that was...