Dove Diner — Restaurant in New York

We went today to have dinner and let me just say this will be our last time going. We were seated in a section that smelled like pee. We asked to be moved. We were moved to a back booth so much better. Our server quickly asked what we wanted to drink. We were brought out pasta salads that were mush and loaded with oil. Pickles and cole slaw weren't too bad. I ordered a California burger which is (burger, raw onion, tomatoes and lettuce) I asked for a side of bacon. My husband got a omelet with home fries and my son mashed potatoes and gravy with chicken tenders.

Let's just say I stopped eating after 4 bites of my burger because it was just flavorless and just gross. After another 10 min of feeding my son, my stomach instantly started gurgling. We had to leave. Also as we were there between the waitress and busboy approaching our table constantly to see if we were done or needed something else it was a bit much. Within 10 min we were approached 5 times between both. My husband asked if they needed the table or something. The waitress apologized when she brought the bill and said her boss was on her. We tipped her well because she was genuine and sweet. Other than that the food was horrible and we will never eat...

A true Staten Island classic — Dove Diner (or the Golden Dove, as long-time locals know it) stands out in a sea of forgettable diners. My recent visit was a refreshing return to what a diner should be.

The food was the highlight: perfectly prepared, beautifully plated omelets, seasoned steak fries that go beyond the usual salt dump, and smoked salmon thick-cut just right. Fresh bagels, clean utensils, and polished granite tabletops elevated the experience further.

The space is large, well-lit, with spotless windows and ample parking — a rare find. Situated on a corner with access to public transit and room for private vehicles, it’s both central and convenient.

A few hardly noticeable drawbacks: the floor could use a bit more attention during the day, some ceiling panels need replacing, and those old plastic cups have outlived their usefulness. I got a greasy menu, and outdated plate designs (bright red and yellow accents) detract slightly from the otherwise well-presented dishes.

Still, this place persists for a reason. It’s not just nostalgia — it’s quality, care, and consistency. I’ll be back.

SI is a treasure trove of good diners. Dove stands out as a...

Git a burger and a wrap. Burger was good but they got the wrap wrong. I said no tomatoes- it had tomatoes, it had no bacon, and no sauce on or on the side. I called and said I want a refund for the wrap. Manager said ok come back. So I went back and the girl working the counter was very nice. Apologized numerous times and tried to make it right. However, the manager was quite the opposite. He went through the wrap and kept mumbling and stuttering trying to make it seem like I'm the bad guy for wanting my money back for them messing up my order. He said at one point when I pointed out there was no sauce on the wrap, "oh the sauce should be on the side anyway." Yea but it wasn't. He didn't apologize once and even short changed me giving me 2 dollars less than the wrap costs. He should take advice from his coworkers on customer service because he lost a customer after this. The food is on par maybe even a step down than the other numerous diners in the area. Avoid this place unless you want to deal with cheap...