Nonna's Pizzeria — Restaurant in New York

We made our own vegan pie with broccoli and black olives and vegan cheese. The pizza came out great! The cheese was melty (surprising for a vegan cheese) and the vegetables were cooked just right. 3 people were able to split a pie and all 3 of us were very satisfied!

We also ordered 3 non vegan veggie slices and one plain cheese pizza slice. The veggie slices were hearty and had a lot of veggies. The only thing they were missing was black olives but other than that they were good according to our non vegan diners!

Staff were great while picking up and kept the slices warm while we waiting for the pie to be made. The shop has the standard NY pizza pie parlor vibe and was nice and sunny and spacious. Overall a great pickup experience and great food. I'm glad they have good vegan and non...

Such a sad looking pizza. Thankfully they had a better cheese slice in the back that I got but I can’t believe they’d put this old dried up pizza up front. Or try to sell it in general.

I hadn’t come here in like a year because my last visit was the same. Very mediocre selection. I gave it another try and… this. The fresher slice I got was better but crust was super thin so the slice would fall apart.

I want this business to do well because I live close and would love some tasty pizza nearby. Hence why I’ve bothered to leave the review.

Oh and staff was cool but one other employee just reached into the garlic knot bowl and took one. Looked like the delivery driver or something. Didn’t seem...

delivery order -- one pizza arrived smushed, crumpled under its own weight on one end it seems? The pizza was too soggy we think, likely not the delivery driver's fault as the second pizza we got wasn't smushed at all.

The smushed one was the white eggplant. The eggplant tasted good, though the pizza was soggy overall and mushy, and it was a red sauce pizza, not white, so I was pretty confused.

The second pizza was a Sicilian with the left side with vegan beef. The vegan beef crumbles were dry and not great. The plain cheese right side was better but still too tough/chewy at places.

Overall a striking disappointment given the reviews I had seen...