Romeo's Pizza — Restaurant in Ohio

I have a question. my family and i are new to Ohio. So far every pizza joint i went to i did not care for. The pizzas were not like the ones back home on Staten island. instead they were square, thick and the crust tasted like cafeteria food. One place made a calzone and it was horrible. it was like eating a giant hot pocket. I wanted to ask how you make the calzones before i order from your pizzeria. I just am frustrated with the food quality so far here in East Liverpool and surrounding areas. Its not a New York thing either. my husband is from Philadelphia and i haven't had any issues with there pizzas. they were not to bad. some places differ with the cheese steaks though. But i have not yet found any good choices with menus. No struffoli, calzones, zeppoles, or anything out here. :(

UPDATE: so i took your word and gave the benefit of the doubt. big mistake. first issue from the jump. i ordered online. i was called back and told you did not have an item. ok, i get things happen. so i switched an item to something else. so here is what ordered for my family.

large half pep and bacon stuffed crust. large calzone philly cheese steak wings mozz sticks.

THE PIZZA, small portion, the crust tasted like pre made boboli on a shelf that expired from walmart weeks in advanced. that is not pizza. it is a cafeteria school pizza that was left in the back of a freezer. gross.

THE CALZONE, small. no ricotta! what the hell is wrong with you people? calzone, fresh tossed dough, smothered in oil, ricotta, fresh mozzarella, baked to perfection. it was a oversized mozz stick. speaking of which.

THE MOZZARELLA STICKS, tasted like premade frozen and tossed in a oil fryer.

WINGS, i don't know what to say. when we lived in Philadelphia there wings, you can smell them. those sob were dripping. you knew what you were getting into. the hot ones made you cry. you dripped with joy. smothered in flavor. these wings were dry.

the worst of it all, THE THING THAT WAS PAWNED AS CHEESE STEAK, GROSS! this thing looked like it was dropped from a vending machine in a hospital ward. no cheese sauce, what the hell was that stuff you tried calling meat? the roll cold! the onions, not sauteed. i gagged when i seen this.

it breaks my heart to see these poor locals mistaken this place for good food. they really do not know what they are missing. sad. never again will i order or eat here. place needs shut...

I ordered a pizza with the deluxe stuffed crust. However, I edited the toppings from the checkout and the crust changed to thin crust. I take the blame for not catching that. But with the toppings, this pizza was $26.50. The pizza was so dry, I lifted up the cheese because I was sure there was no sauce. To my surprise, there was a small amount of sauce. Maybe the normal crust would have been better. The large pizza was advertised to be 14 inches. Nope, 12.5 inches across. But what really ruined it for me was that the bacon and ham that I ordered was only on the middle of the pizza. The way the pizza was cut, only the 4 middle pieces had bacon and ham. I guess I should be happy some of the other toppings made it on to the rest of the pizza. In the end, it was not worth the cost at all. My total bill was $57 for 2 pizzas, and 2 lbs of wings. My first time trying this place is my last. I don't recommend this...

Wow. Just wow! We moved here in October and have been sticking to what we know (Fox's, Pizza Hut, Domino's...). That gets old after a while. In comes Google to save the Sunday! Didn't want to go through the hassle of going and getting food, pizza normally fills my family up, done! Was confused about the size of a full sheet and how it compared to Fox's big daddy, so we called. The young lady that answered the phone was very helpful and friendly. She explained the reason they were a bit more expensive than other places as well as the size of the pizzas. I placed my order online and it said it would be here in an hour. 25 minutes later my doorbell is ringing! The flavor of these things is phenomenal!! We are a family of 6 and I was skeptical about the amount of pizza we were getting. But we didn't even finish half of it! I will honestly order...