Pizza My Way — Restaurant in Pacific Grove

Recommended by my boss, a coworker and I decided to try this pizza joint out. Indeed we were recommended well.

A small quaint quiet building. A mural on the wall depicting a local favorite spot, Lovers point. The painting is epic. Accompanied by others flash card size drawings posted along side a designated art area. That's always fun, having paper and something to draw with whilst your waiting.

The place was empty just my coworker and I with quite the amount of people coming in to pick up an order

Well lit with an Italian vibe , that reminds me of Tuscany. Plenty of seating, including for children. Childrens chairs available.

A wide variety of options to choose from all the way from of course pizza , salads, calzones and kid friendly choices as well. Different types of beverages from soda to orange juice and of course wine and beer. Nice small cut limes complemented a nice cold Modelo beer. The pizza was cooked well. No burned spots or saggy dough. The toppings did not oversaturate or over covered the surface. The pizza taste evenly and better than it looked. Highly impressed by the presentation of the food. Chicken wings available. Well cooked through and through . We tried the buffalo wings were tender, the meat was nice and white with a balance of flavor. The spicy level was mild. Nice orange coat on a white plate presented itself as delicious as it looked exquisite.

Parking seems limited but it might depend on the days. We found parking easily and readily available. The hostess was welcoming and very helpful. Let us take our time and even asked us a few questions about ourselves. The area is safe and well lit right on one of the main streets of that area. The restroom was clean. The atmosphere was calm and the price was reasonable .

I will definitely be going back to try other...

It pains me to give Pizza My Way a low review. I have been ordering and eating their pizza since 2012. Today, for the first time, I decided to eat at the restaurant rather than order out.

There were four of us. My daughter, her husband, my 9-year-old grandaughter, and I. We arrived around 12:30 pm and the place was deserted. I remarked to my children that usually, a restaurant that was empty at lunch time on a Sunday was not a good omen.

We were told to choose anyplace to sit. We selected a table, in the corner. I noticed that my son-in-law started to sweep the table and chairs with his hand to clear up crumbs and other debris. On inspection, it was evident that all the tables were dirty. Some had dozens of greasy hand prints on them.

We ordered a combination pizza (1/2 cheese, 1/2 pineapple and onions) The pizza was not up to the usual level. The crust was totally devoid of salt, which made the taste like cardboard. All in all, at best a 5 out of 10 pizza.

I don't know if the management has changed or what is the reason for the decline in quality. I have decided not to patronize Pizza My Way from...

The pizza was great! Best I had in PG or Monterey. My fiance got a late night hunger so we went looking for somewhere to eat at 900 p.m. We found this shop on Yelp so we showed up before closing and who I'm assuming is the owner still told us no worries take a seat. We ordered simple pepperoni just because we felt bad we were there late. I didn't expect much just because I've passed by the place 100 times and never noticed it. Well let me tell you I was very impressed, the cheese was quality mozzarella and the sauce had to be home made and it was just the right amount not to much or too little. Now for me the crust is what brought it home for me. Im a thick crust and my lady is a New York style pizza and she it was crusty no bready.... her words..lol It was thick but cooked so the bottom was crisp but not burnt and had good flavor. I have to say I definitely will be going...