Nick-N-Willy's Pizza Peoria — Restaurant in Peoria

Taste of the food- absolutely outstanding! And if you dine in a baguette of cheese garlic bread was only four dollars.

I did take out the other night, and got a family size pizza with 2-5 toppings (depending on how they charge for cheese). When I placed the order over the phone I was not told a total. I picked up my order and it came out to $38, which is pretty outrageous for just one pizza. I tipped and left since I had already ordered.

A friend of my went shortly after me, and she said they automatically added tip onto the bill.

I didn't realize it until I left, but when I requested a receipt, it wasn't an itemized receipt, so I can't tell if that happened to me or not.

I have since went on doordash to price compare. I qualify for free delivery, and it looks like they charged EIGHT DOLLARS to add bacon on a pick up order.

It was great pizza but it's just really not feasible to pay that much for a topping for...

Do I think this is world class pizza? No. But do I think it’s delicious? Yes. Let’s start with this place being in Peoria for ages, and I am late to the game in trying it but I was very impressed. The flavor of the pizza is great, I ordered the chicken and bacon, on a thin crust and it was very good. I also ordered the cheese bread, and that’s truly what will have me come back again The cheese was so soft and had the best cheese pull with a slight garlicky flavor and crispy crunchy outside. I would quite literally order that bread and pile toppings on it and have a great night. Besides that- the employees are so nice. Bringing us extra plates, dipping sauce , and being so welcoming. That’s what makes this place a 5 star. The pizza is great but the people are even better.

Will be going here for all of my pizza and cheese...

My most recent experience would have been about my third time ordering pizza from here and I have always received a great product each time. I arrived to pickup my order this time and needed to wait a few minutes for them to finish. When I was given my pizza I was also given an apology along with a second pizza for free. It was explained that the first pizza they made accidently had a different type of sausage than what I had ordered and that it was promptly remade. Most would have ignored the issue and hoped I didn't catch it. Thank you for the honesty and the delicious food. I highly recommend...