Mighty Fine Pizza — Restaurant in Petoskey

Visited Mighty Fine pizza last night. I am Italian and grew up in a pizza shop. This is some good pizza! The sauce isn’t that authentic tasting-just okay.

I shared a super with my son that was great! Amount of items were very fair. I liked it better cold today than hot last night. My daughter got a cheese pizza that at first looked burnt but tasted good. Both my kiddos don’t care for crust and Mighty Fine seems to have larger crust sizes so that was a negative for them but their crust is good. My boyfriend got a Gluten Free pizza which he didn’t mind-just wished the crust was cooked more thoroughly. Doesn’t seem like it was prebaked like it should have. We got a small order of breadsticks that were buttery but could have used more garlic. We also got two different salads, Antipasto ane Cesar, that were large for the price. Both were delicious and fresh.

The staff was very kind and professional both on the phone and during pick up. Great little pizza joint to visit and check out...

We were excited to try after reading so many great reviews. We ordered the BBQ Chicken pizza and cheese sticks. We also asked for marinara sauce for the cheese sticks. Came out to $39 after tax and we added a $5 tip for the driver. Over an hour later we get get the food. No marinara sauce :( which is a shame because the cheese sticks were dry as chalk and had way too much garlic. Took a bite of the pizza and immediately noticed the marinara sauce was in my BBQ chicken pizza??? I ate 1 slice and was ready to chuck it right back up. The cubed up chicken was barely hot and tasted like chunks of rubber. I check the receipt to see if maybe it was wrote on the ticket wrong and also noticed they decided to tip the driver $6 instead of $5… Didn’t bother calling back… Fast forward 6 hours I spent 2 hours on the toilet in the middle of the night and been burping up what I am going to call the worst pizza...

Mighty Fine Pizza is the perfect description of this place. I’ve eaten at gourmet pizza restaurants, I’ve eaten at humble fast food pizza joints but this place has rocketed to my number one favorite pizza.

My wife and I were looking for a place to eat while in town for some errands and we happened to see this place on google. We swung by and we’re caught off guard at how small it was. We ordered a BBQ chicken pizza and some cheese sticks. When I say that this is the best pizza crust you will ever have I am not exaggerating. It was fluffy and chewy and cooked to perfection. The toppings were fresh and delicious. Service was quick and friendly. I would recommend this place to pizza lovers and folks looking for a...