HTML SitemapExplore
logo
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants

Pioneer Pizza — Restaurant in Plain City

Name
Pioneer Pizza
Description
Unassuming, family-friendly hangout with pizza, pasta, subs & children’s movies.
Nearby attractions
Hammer & Stain Plain City
153 A W Main St, Plain City, OH 43064
Plain City Public Library
305 W Main St, Plain City, OH 43064
Nearby restaurants
The Grainery
138 W Main St, Plain City, OH 43064
The Clocktower Kitchen + Bar
101 S Chillicothe St, Plain City, OH 43064
Lee's Sports & Spirits
209 W Bigelow Ave, Plain City, OH 43064
Drink Up
179 E Main St, Plain City, OH 43064
Buckeye Pizza
209 W Bigelow Ave, Plain City, OH 43064
NickaLena's
209 W Bigelow Ave, Plain City, OH 43064
Der Dutchman
445 Jefferson Ave, Plain City, OH 43064
Domino's Pizza
553 W Main St, Plain City, OH 43064, United States
McDonald's
200 Jefferson Ave, Plain City, OH 43064
Nearby hotels
Pastime Park
370 N Chillicothe St, Plain City, OH 43064
Related posts
Keywords
Pioneer Pizza tourism.Pioneer Pizza hotels.Pioneer Pizza bed and breakfast. flights to Pioneer Pizza.Pioneer Pizza attractions.Pioneer Pizza restaurants.Pioneer Pizza travel.Pioneer Pizza travel guide.Pioneer Pizza travel blog.Pioneer Pizza pictures.Pioneer Pizza photos.Pioneer Pizza travel tips.Pioneer Pizza maps.Pioneer Pizza things to do.
Pioneer Pizza things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Pioneer Pizza
United StatesOhioPlain CityPioneer Pizza

Basic Info

Pioneer Pizza

132 N Chillicothe St, Plain City, OH 43064
4.3(169)
order
order
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

Unassuming, family-friendly hangout with pizza, pasta, subs & children’s movies.

attractions: Hammer & Stain Plain City, Plain City Public Library, restaurants: The Grainery, The Clocktower Kitchen + Bar, Lee's Sports & Spirits, Drink Up, Buckeye Pizza, NickaLena's, Der Dutchman, Domino's Pizza, McDonald's
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(614) 873-2404
Website
pioneerpizza.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Plain City
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Plain City
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Plain City
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
dish
Funnel Cake Fries
dish
Mac & Cheese Bites
dish
Potato Skins
dish
Bone-In Wings
dish
Boneless Wings
dish
Mozzarella Sticks (6)
dish
French Fries
dish
Buckeye Bites & Beer Cheese
dish
Cream Cheese Jalapeno Poppers (6)
dish
Pickle Fries
dish
Italian Sub
dish
Pizza Sub
dish
Ham & Cheese Sub
dish
Turkey Sub
dish
BLT Sub
dish
Meatball Sub
dish
Veggie Sub
dish
Club Sub
dish
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
dish
Buffalo Chicken Sub
dish
Super Sub
dish
Garlic Bread W/ Cheese
dish
Bread Sticks
dish
House Salad
dish
Antipasto Salad
dish
Grilled Chicken Salad
dish
Crispy Chicken Salad
dish
Taco Salad
dish
10" Original Stromboli Build Your Own
dish
10" Original Stromboli All The Way
dish
10" Original Stromboli All Meat
dish
10" Original Stromboli BBQ Chicken
dish
10" Original Stromboli Hawaiian
dish
10" Original Stromboli Old Fashion
dish
10" Original Stromboli Buffalo Chicken
dish
10" Original Stromboli Chicken Bacon Ranch
dish
10" Original Stromboli Veggie
dish
12" Original Stromboli Build Your Own
dish
12" Original Stromboli All The Way
dish
12" Original Stromboli All Meat
dish
12" Original Stromboli BBQ Chicken
dish
12" Original Stromboli Hawaiian
dish
12" Original Stromboli Old Fashion
dish
12" Original Stromboli Buffalo Chicken
dish
12" Original Stromboli Chicken Bacon Ranch
dish
12" Original Stromboli Veggie
dish
14" Original Stromboli Build Your Own
dish
14" Original Stromboli All The Way
dish
14" Original Stromboli All Meat
dish
14" Original Stromboli BBQ Chicken
dish
14" Original Stromboli Hawaiian
dish
14" Original Stromboli Old Fashion
dish
14" Original Stromboli Buffalo Chicken
dish
14" Original Stromboli Chicken Bacon Ranch
dish
14" Original Stromboli Veggie
dish
16" Original Stromboli Build Your Own
dish
16" Original Stromboli All The Way
dish
16" Original Stromboli All Meat
dish
16" Original Stromboli Chicken Bacon Ranch
dish
16" Original Stromboli BBQ Chicken
dish
16" Original Stromboli Buffalo Chicken
dish
16" Original Stromboli Hawaiian
dish
16" Original Stromboli Old Fashion
dish
16" Original Stromboli Veggie
dish
12" FS Build Your Own
dish
12" FS All The Way
dish
12" FS All Meat
dish
12" FS BBQ Chicken
dish
12" FS Hawaiian
dish
12" FS Old Fashion
dish
12" FS Buffalo Chicken
dish
12" FS Chicken Bacon Ranch
dish
12" FS Veggie
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Build Your Own
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli All The Way
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli All Meat
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli BBQ Chicken
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Hawaiian
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Old Fashion
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Buffalo Chicken
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Chicken Bacon Ranch
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Veggie
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Build Your Own
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli All The Way
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli All Meat
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli BBQ Chicken
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Hawaiian
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Old Fashion
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Buffalo Chicken
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Chicken Bacon Ranch
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Veggie
dish
12" FS All The Way
dish
12" FS Chicken Bacon Ranch
dish
12" FS BBQ Chicken
dish
12" FS Buffalo Chicken
dish
12" FS Build Your Own
dish
12" FS Hawaiian
dish
12" FS All Meat
dish
12" FS Old Fashion
dish
12" FS Veggie
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli All The Way
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Chicken Bacon Ranch
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli BBQ Chicken
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Buffalo Chicken
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Build Your Own
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Hawaiian
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli All Meat
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Old Fashion
dish
14" Dawsons Stromboli Veggie
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli All The Way
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Chicken Bacon Ranch
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli BBQ Chicken
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Buffalo Chicken
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Build Your Own
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Hawaiian
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli All Meat
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Old Fashion
dish
16" Dawsons Stromboli Veggie

Reviews

Nearby attractions of Pioneer Pizza

Hammer & Stain Plain City

Plain City Public Library

Hammer & Stain Plain City

Hammer & Stain Plain City

4.9

(16)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
Plain City Public Library

Plain City Public Library

4.7

(26)

Open until 8:00 PM
Click for details

Things to do nearby

Kid Quest in Columbus: Superhero City Adventure for Kids (Ages 4–8)
Kid Quest in Columbus: Superhero City Adventure for Kids (Ages 4–8)
Mon, Dec 1 • 12:00 AM
1000 City Park Ave, 43206
View details
Columbus, OH Murder Mystery: Solve the case!
Columbus, OH Murder Mystery: Solve the case!
Mon, Dec 1 • 12:00 AM
937 S 3rd St, Columbus, OH 43206, USA, 43206
View details
Explore Columbus on The Trolley Pub
Explore Columbus on The Trolley Pub
Thu, Dec 11 • 12:00 PM
Howell Township, 07731
View details

Nearby restaurants of Pioneer Pizza

The Grainery

The Clocktower Kitchen + Bar

Lee's Sports & Spirits

Drink Up

Buckeye Pizza

NickaLena's

Der Dutchman

Domino's Pizza

McDonald's

The Grainery

The Grainery

4.3

(372)

Click for details
The Clocktower Kitchen + Bar

The Clocktower Kitchen + Bar

4.5

(54)

Click for details
Lee's Sports & Spirits

Lee's Sports & Spirits

4.5

(145)

Click for details
Drink Up

Drink Up

5.0

(27)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.
logo

Reviews of Pioneer Pizza

4.3
(169)
avatar
5.0
7y

Been following this place on Facebook since they opened and I made the trip there which was worth it even now in hungry for it. I got the all the way with pineapple, The dough is natural not bunch of modifies, sugar very symmetrical, consistant crust, texture all in house made, the topping were good the mushrooms, veggies were fresh cut onto pizza making it wholesome and delicious, the sauce is very paletable good tomato base, its not the generic, canned sauces, or added bunch of sugar, salts to make you want it, but good recipe base. The peporinie were over layed over another giving you beautiful bite an combination of fully cooked crust with a soft crunch, pairing of sauce the cheese, peoprine, then veggies. I absolutely love it ive been a hound dogs, Giordanios person for awhile but ive meet my match next is the taco pizza and a sub! And I there dinning area is very calm, and inviting area with good acomdations, comfortable seating, and all the ementies for your pizza even crayons for kids to use, the place is good for a meeting, get together, or night time...

   Read more
avatar
3.0
21w

Please fix your customer service at the front desk at Plain City Pioneer pizza.... This is just FYI.....we love your wings, salads, and pizza. And when we're in town we always order your food. Last 3x there is NOBODY at the front desk to assist customers. All the employees fixing pizzas look at you like your in the wrong place..... Please see if you can revise the front customer desk so they are more available..... Tonight I waited more than 5 mins ....while the kitchen staff watched me.. Finally a girl drinking from a water cup came in and never acknowledged me. Finally I walked around the counter and loudly asked "if I was to get my own pizza??"....then they all looked at me and the girl with the water bottle finally asked if she could help me....yes I want my pizza!!! I ordered online...paid online ...and I could see it sitting on the oven.

Please review your policies and procedures for customers....my apologies to your staff.....I had a busy day that didn't...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
3y

Really wish I could give a review on the pizza, but I sure have one on the service. Arrived at 550 on a Friday Night. We ordered one large one topping pizza. Gave them the table number as requested by the bartender that took our order. We had a soccer match for our son that would be starting at 730 so we thought we would be good on time. Absolutely not the case. By 645 no pizza, so I drive my son to his game and the wife stays back to wait for the pizza. By 705 still no pizza. We gotta go, so the wife asks some random waitress what's going on. She says...oh we gave your pizza to someone else we can have something out in 5 minutes. 10 minutes later I asked for a refund. We'll see if it goes through. I hate giving poor reviews but thus one is deserving...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next

Posts

Jamal jabariJamal jabari
Been following this place on Facebook since they opened and I made the trip there which was worth it even now in hungry for it. I got the all the way with pineapple, The dough is natural not bunch of modifies, sugar very symmetrical, consistant crust, texture all in house made, the topping were good the mushrooms, veggies were fresh cut onto pizza making it wholesome and delicious, the sauce is very paletable good tomato base, its not the generic, canned sauces, or added bunch of sugar, salts to make you want it, but good recipe base. The peporinie were over layed over another giving you beautiful bite an combination of fully cooked crust with a soft crunch, pairing of sauce the cheese, peoprine, then veggies. I absolutely love it ive been a hound dogs, Giordanios person for awhile but ive meet my match next is the taco pizza and a sub! And I there dinning area is very calm, and inviting area with good acomdations, comfortable seating, and all the ementies for your pizza even crayons for kids to use, the place is good for a meeting, get together, or night time dinner cravings.
X JohnsonX Johnson
Very underwhelming experience. One of the pizzas had a bubble so big it rendered half the pizza inedible; how does this make it past any kind of quality check at 4:30 on a Wednesday? Not exactly a dinner rush time. As far as the Italian subs? Meh. The dressing had no flavor and was just oil and vinegar. Definitely check your food before you leave. Also, there are separate entrances for the cashier and dinning room, which is odd. Edit, 1 year later: After moving back to the area we decided to give them another chance, still bad. The Italian dressing is still flavorless and they used lettuce that was brown and wilted. The pizza was still just ok; at least this time it was cooked correctly without the huge bubble. Will not be returning.
Debbie ThompsonDebbie Thompson
Found this place by total luck. My brother and I were on our way home from Columbus and decided to take the back roads instead of the interstate. We both said we'd like to find a mom and pop pizza place for lunch. We stop at a red light, I glance to my right and said hey there's a pizza place. Super friendly gal took our order and made our pizza and brought it to our table. We literally had THE most amazing pickle fries ever. I know from now on I am going to be disappointed in any others but theirs. The pizza was superb! Loaded so high with toppings but yet no soggy crust. And let me add that the toppings were very fresh. It wasn't just great food, it was an experience.
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Plain City

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Been following this place on Facebook since they opened and I made the trip there which was worth it even now in hungry for it. I got the all the way with pineapple, The dough is natural not bunch of modifies, sugar very symmetrical, consistant crust, texture all in house made, the topping were good the mushrooms, veggies were fresh cut onto pizza making it wholesome and delicious, the sauce is very paletable good tomato base, its not the generic, canned sauces, or added bunch of sugar, salts to make you want it, but good recipe base. The peporinie were over layed over another giving you beautiful bite an combination of fully cooked crust with a soft crunch, pairing of sauce the cheese, peoprine, then veggies. I absolutely love it ive been a hound dogs, Giordanios person for awhile but ive meet my match next is the taco pizza and a sub! And I there dinning area is very calm, and inviting area with good acomdations, comfortable seating, and all the ementies for your pizza even crayons for kids to use, the place is good for a meeting, get together, or night time dinner cravings.
Jamal jabari

Jamal jabari

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Plain City

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Very underwhelming experience. One of the pizzas had a bubble so big it rendered half the pizza inedible; how does this make it past any kind of quality check at 4:30 on a Wednesday? Not exactly a dinner rush time. As far as the Italian subs? Meh. The dressing had no flavor and was just oil and vinegar. Definitely check your food before you leave. Also, there are separate entrances for the cashier and dinning room, which is odd. Edit, 1 year later: After moving back to the area we decided to give them another chance, still bad. The Italian dressing is still flavorless and they used lettuce that was brown and wilted. The pizza was still just ok; at least this time it was cooked correctly without the huge bubble. Will not be returning.
X Johnson

X Johnson

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Plain City

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Found this place by total luck. My brother and I were on our way home from Columbus and decided to take the back roads instead of the interstate. We both said we'd like to find a mom and pop pizza place for lunch. We stop at a red light, I glance to my right and said hey there's a pizza place. Super friendly gal took our order and made our pizza and brought it to our table. We literally had THE most amazing pickle fries ever. I know from now on I am going to be disappointed in any others but theirs. The pizza was superb! Loaded so high with toppings but yet no soggy crust. And let me add that the toppings were very fresh. It wasn't just great food, it was an experience.
Debbie Thompson

Debbie Thompson

See more posts
See more posts