Godfather's Pizza Express — Restaurant in Pueblo

Not gonna lie, really wish I could leave a negative review here. I cant comment on the food quality, but I highly encourage anyone who intends to order pizza from this location to call ahead to ensure their ovens are turned on. We found out the hard way. We had ordered our pizza for pickup at around 9:15 pm but were told that "they didn't see our order and their ovens had been turned off for 3 HOURS due to an inspection the next day". It gets better. We were also told that because we ordered the pizza through a 3rd party (the Godfathers website) they couldn't issue us a refund and that we'd have to call Godfathers tomorrow to have it sorted out. Which means, instead of the pending money being automatically released back to our card, we will now probably have to wait 2 to 5 business days to get the over 30 USD back if the charge clears before they reverse it. So I encourage you to pay in store/use cash. Now while they did "offer us Subway" for the inconvenience, we couldn't accept it because our autistic son will not eat sandwiches due to strong food aversions. I'm seriously upset. I get that I'm rambling but now it's too late to order food we can afford from anywhere else since we are tight on money as is. It's no wonder that where we are from all the Godfathers locations are now sleeping with the fishes. Had just really hoped to share what I had whole heartedly believed to be the best pizza with my kids, but I absolutely will not make this mistake a second time. (And yeah, I get ordering pizza is expensive but it was a celebratory meal for our kids. So yeah, whole experience has been a real kick...

Well seriously not happy with this place. First encounter the guy making the pizza forgot the cheese but he made it right. He put cheese on ran it back through the oven without burning the thin crustand plus he didn't charge us. Even though I insisted he wouldn't charge us. Today we ordered on line and went shopping at pet smart while pizza is being made. We arrived after the pick up time and the lady told us that the order hadn't come through till now, 30+minutes. And they where out of chicken and they do not carry sun dried tomatoes. It took another twenty minutes and she still did not get the order correct. Tired and hungry didn't make a scene. For my wife's sake, she likes thier pizza, maybe I will give them...

It's in a GAS STATION. I feel this needs to be said. The pizza is great. I could talk all day about the pizza. There was plenty of sauce and cheese on our pepperoni pizza. The crust is what had me over the top. It has that great color on the bottom only a well seasoned pan can give. The crust is buttery and crispy on the outside, slight chew but soft inside. Of course the atmosphere is going to be lacking b/c it's in a GAS STATION. If you are looking for a Triple "D" joint, this isn't for you...But I'd say it's worth a...