Piece of Cake - Gourmet Gelatos, Ice Creams & Sorbets — Restaurant in Rahway

What a delish!!! I went today for the first time because I've seen great reviews and because I love ice cream...I took my son for his birthday and we were greeted by the (whom I think is) owner who instantly was very welcoming and nice, did not catch your name but thank you so much for being so kind and gifting my son what he chose as his birthday order. I also bought a sampler and a few other individual ice cream varieties and I was amazed by how delicious and just beautiful everything was...loved every single slice!!! My favorites however...key lime pie, the pecan one and the nutty/almond/ chocolate one (have to get the correct names but those were superb. I highly recommend this business and if I could give 10 stars I would!! Thank you for making my son's...

All I can say is Wowweee Wow!!!! We were highly recommended a few times from family and friends and finally we went which is only 15 minutes from us. We get to Piece of Cake and everyone was so helpful and friendly. Their selection honestly was super fresh and precisely the perfect temp. We order some to stay and to take home. Again wowwee wow as we had the apple pie and blueberry pie this was an ora of super smiley faces as people were enjoying their tasty icecream/gelato. Our taste buds were truly in heaven. We brought some home for our family and when friends come over and they were so surprised between the taste and texture it was Truly Beyond!!! We are definitely hooked and we will be back and yes we also highly recommend...

Piece of Cake has the kind of ice cream which will make you question why you have stuck with Haagen Daaz or Friendly's. The richness of their flavors pretty much makes it where you have to tell yourself to actively stop because "Just a little bit more" will end up you eating the whole thing.

I should note though, you could easily pass the storefront, which is behind a house, they are cash only, and their retail space is fairly new, so everything you see on the website isn't available. Especially in consumer sizes since they've mostly done wholesale but are slowly, but surely, adapting to also sell to people who just want a pint of ice cream, pieces of cake, and things of...