Lucy's Cake Shop
Lucy's Cake Shop things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
I ordered a cake for my gender reveal, and look I’ve been ordering cakes from Lucy’s for years as well as all my family! They even made my cake for my wedding. I’m so disappointed and upset with the service this time from ordering- to the actual cake. I walked in on a Friday and got some girl with a terrible attitude and when I asked her if they did the white gender reveal cakes she looked at me like I was asking a stupid question and gave me a book. I explained I just wanted a white cake with pink filling. She never asked me what tone of pink she just assumed and wrote down light pink on the ticket. When we sliced the cake everyone was confused because we couldn’t see the color, we had to basically pull the cake apart to see that it was pink. The problem with this business is the people they have working the front desk that don’t take their time in asking details and then they blame the customer. This girl basically wrote whatever she wanted and used that receipt to say I ordered light pink when I wasn’t even asked what tone. Or at least put enough filling to where we can see it, the cake ain’t cheap! And just like you have to buy your supplies and pay your decorators, I have to work hard for that $ I chose to spend there & then for yall not to offer a refund it’s ridiculous. Just dusted your hands and kept with your day. Been trying to have a baby for 10 years and my moment was ruined. Just won’t buy or trust yall with these important life moments anymore.
N PN P
80
Ordered a birthday cake from here for the 4th time this year. We were regular customers up until 2018 then we stopped coming here until earlier this year. Our experiences this year were awesome, the cakes are always delicious and very well priced! This time we ordered a cake that feeds 15 people and were charged $75 (Photo of the cake we ordered is attached). I normally order cakes to feed 10 people, last time I ordered a Green Bay cake that fed 15 people and it was $40. We were told it was $15 extra for the white flowers, and pearls on the cake. We paid but not really sure why it was $75 and can't justify spending that much money on a cake to feed maybe 12 people at a small dinner. I tried speaking with them to not put the flowers on the day before we were due to pick up the cake but was told it was too late even though we were told the person doing the flowers wasn't going to be able to decorate the cake until the day the cake would be picked up. Sadly we won't be ordering from here anymore. Only reason we constantly ordered was because of the prices, we live too far away to continue making the drive for the cakes anymore.
Amanda K.Amanda K.
10
We ordered the first layer of the two story cake in the second picture. The lady said it would be $130 including the number 6 on the top that was meant to be done in fondant. The first picture is what we got from Lucy’s. The green buttercream was very sloppy and wrong green. The fondant used to make the ‘creeper’s’ face is so sloppy too. Just look at the picture. Does not look like it was done by a professional. They said that it was that much money because of the fondant they needed to use for the square. But they didn’t add any of the other squares around the cake to make it ‘pixelated looking’. It looks like a cake we baked at home. But we would’ve put more effort into the details and saved a lot of money. The number 6 that they were supposed to make in fondant, was just a piece of paper with glitter (look at pictures). Definitely not the #6 they made us pay $20 more for when we order it. Definitely do not recommend this place, unless you want a disappointing cake for your special day. Flavor was ok. Compares to HEB cakes, which taste good but are a lot cheaper and nicer looking.
Z LaSalleZ LaSalle
50
I was able to place a birthday cake order at the last minute. No crazy fee or price. And my daughter's cake came out EXACTLY how we ordered. No complaints. I am very happy with their customer service and product. **2022 UPDATE**, I once again ordered my daughter's birthday cake from Lucy's, and it was SO beautiful, I didn't want to cut it. 😩 I am so grateful for their service. They are outstanding, and I absolutely appreciate how every detail was done with care. Thanks again, it was beautiful and delicious!!❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏 ***7/02/24 UPDATE*** Lucy's done did it again!!! She just doesn't disappoint me, each time I've introduced a particular design I'm aiming for! Look at the stunning birthday cake she made for my husband!! I asked for a specific nail gun, and she knocked it out of the park with the detail. Thanks again guys! I'll see you again soon!
Griselda GarciaGriselda Garcia
30
The birthday cake we ordered was absolutely incredible! It not only looked stunning but tasted even better. The vanilla/chocolate was incredibly moist, and the layers of filling with buttercream frosting were perfectly balanced—not too sweet, but just right. The attention to detail on the custom design was impressive; it captured the theme of the party perfectly, and the colors were vibrant and fun. Everyone at the party loved it and couldn’t stop talking about how delicious it was. I really appreciated how accommodating the cake shop was with our request. The customer service was top-notch from start to finish. This cake truly made the celebration special, and I would highly recommend Lucy's to anyone looking for a show-stopping cake for any occasion. The cake super exceeded our expectations! We will definitely be ordering from them again!
Roxanne SheehanRoxanne Sheehan
00
Nearby Attractions Of Lucy's Cake Shop
H-E-B plus!
San Antonio Marketplace
Marbach Square
Palm Harbor Homes - San Antonio

H-E-B plus!
4.4
(2.9K)Click for details

San Antonio Marketplace
4.2
(1K)Click for details

Marbach Square
4.3
(361)Click for details

Palm Harbor Homes - San Antonio
4.3
(244)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Lucy's Cake Shop
San Antonio Incredible Pizza Company
El Bucanero - Marbach
Jim's Restaurants
Apetitos mexican restaurant
Gilberts Mexican Restaurant LLC
Golden Wok
El Rodeo Mexican Grill #5
Asia Kitchen
Tealicious Cafe
Chong's Korean Restaurant

San Antonio Incredible Pizza Company
4.3
(3.1K)$$
Click for details

El Bucanero - Marbach
4.2
(1.3K)$$
Click for details

Jim's Restaurants
4.2
(1.1K)Click for details

Apetitos mexican restaurant
4.3
(671)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
2030 SW Loop 410, San Antonio, TX 78227
Map
Phone
(210) 673-5965
Call
Website
lucycakeshop.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.3
(427 reviews)$$
Ratings & Description
Description
Bakery offering military & wedding cakes, plus flavored cupcakes & home baking products.
attractions: H-E-B plus!, San Antonio Marketplace, Marbach Square, Palm Harbor Homes - San Antonio, restaurants: San Antonio Incredible Pizza Company, El Bucanero - Marbach, Jim's Restaurants, Apetitos mexican restaurant, Gilberts Mexican Restaurant LLC, Golden Wok, El Rodeo Mexican Grill #5, Asia Kitchen, Tealicious Cafe, Chong's Korean Restaurant
The Hit List
