Shawna Rae's Treats & Eats — Restaurant in Shipshewana

This bakery and Café is amazing! We came here after leaving The Shipshawana Auction Restaurant without eating (overpriced bar fare food menu, cheap diner feel and atmosphere) and were thrilled with the food! We had the Southwest Chicken Salad and Ham and Cheese Wrap and both were fresh, plentiful and tasty. We couldn’t leave without buying six amazing cupcakes for $13 and the best turtle ice cream we’ve ever eaten. This bakery/cafe has a small town, mom and pop feel to it with great food, friendly staff and reasonable prices. We use Trip Advisor for recommendations when traveling and this place was not listed but I’m attempting to remedy that as we are so pleased we found it on a Google search. It did...

Shawna Rae had such patient and friendly staffs and not to mention big, yummy portions of foods with affordable price! Hubby got a monster Reuben and it was HUGE and really meaty and cheesy with perfect sourness for the sauerkraut!! The BBQ chicken haystack was delicious and hearty too! The one we want to give a HUGE shoutout was the cheesecake- we got the lemon blueberry cheesecake and we finished the whole thing on the spot because it was that yummy. The cheesecake has a balance of sweetness and it was interestingly light and fluffy with the whip cream, cheesecake and homemade blueberry jam. It was the most delicious cheesecake I’ve eaten in a while. Definitely worth...

Caution for those with CELIAC needing not just gluten free ingredients but also no cross contact.

Tried their GF peach cheesecake and had a definite gluten reaction. Most likely cross contact - especially since the GF cheesecake was on bottom shelf of display case with all regular cheesecakes beside and above them. Not sure if GF items are made in same kitchen or what procedures they use to protect during prep and baking.

May be fine for those slightly intolerant of gluten but definitely would not recommend for those...