America's Pie Tinicum — Restaurant in Tinicum Township

I’ve been using America’s Pie Catering for a few years and they never disappoint! In fact, they keep getting better and their catering menu has grown since we discovered them. Doesn’t matter the occasion, whether you’re planning a party, work meeting/event, or you just want to host Sunday football or work meeting/event, big or small, America’s Pie has got you covered.

I referred a friend, when her initial caterer cancelled 9 days before my Goddaughter’s communion party, and America’s Pie understood the assignment. They went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. My friends were impressed with their delivery service. The driver set up the food tables made sure the burners were lit and food ready to go before leaving. Everyone loved the food.

Roast beef, mac & cheese, and meatballs are our usual picks for informal parties. The half roast beef tray is perfect for Sunday football dinner with family and a couple friends. The meatballs are perfectly sized for sandwiches and so tasty. I’ve had their filet at a party I attended and it was perfectly cooked and so tender.

The entire America’s Pie Crew are awesome and their customer service is out of this world!! I’ve mostly worked with Mechelle, the catering manager at Tinicum, and she’s super friendly, helpful, and great at guiding me through my selections and so accommodating, especially on amounts based on headcount, event type, and dietary needs. Once I make contact with Mechelle, I know everything will be taken care of and I can focus on other tasks for my parties.

THANK YOU Matt, George, Mechelle, and the America’s Pie family for your amazing...

Food is incredible. Very good a huge step up from pizza shop food. Original sandwiches you can't get anywhere else. Can't say enough about the food quality. BUT with that said it is expensive definitely over priced. I spent $60.00+ on two taco platters a sandwhich and smoked gouda bites delivery. I live 2 mins drive from here and my food was ice cold. Ridiculously cold. Unacceptably cold. I did call them to complain just to make it known. I wasn't going ask for replacement food or even my money back, which i should have. I was given credit on the tacos for next time i order but i have to call and mention it, im guessing its noted in my account there. Online account was made prior to this but in my account there is nothing stating i have a credit at all. It does show the 10 reward i earned from previous orders. So won't know if the credit will be honored until i order again. We will see. But yes great food when it is hot when its suppose to be. I don't recommend delivery for this reason especially since i live so close, same town 1-2 min drive. Also the prices are high. Understandable partially since the quality and choices are great but still not even a place i could order from weekly or even monthly. A once in awhile thing. For one person its a little more doable but still easily spend 20 on one item...

Well it just goes to prove, peoples taste in Pizza is truly subjective. I trusted the hype of this place and was left largely underwhelmed. Ordered 3 types of pizza to get a decent variety of the quality of pies. I chose takeout on a weekend at early dinner time. At the time I was there, I heard a voice instructed the employees to notify customers that deliveries are to be backlogged 1.5 hrs. (They were very busy) everyone seemed "on-point and polite. And I very much appreciated that.) The food- The good.. A decent amount of choices (mostly typical pizza and deli offerings hot&cold) Service was quick even though it was ridiculously hot in there. Not too expensive. The bad.. Sauce was lacking in 2 critical areas for pizza choices. I found it much blander than most places I've eaten from. and 2. Our pizzas were so very sparsely dressed with Sauce that one would think they were running out of Sauce. One of my pizzas choices was an upside-down pie which is normally covered in pizza sauce and this was definitely not. Taste.. reminds me of any generic boardwalk pizza you could get anywhere. Like I said unfortunately "unremarkable taste experience " Crust was just ok.. actually a bit undercooked for my liking. Result Not sure if I will be back, this experience wasn't worth the...