Brunello's Pizza & Pasta of West Babylon New York — Restaurant in Town of Babylon

This place has great potential. They have a nice owner, good sauce, and COULD be among the very best around. Unfortunately theyre very stingy with the cheese even if you ask and pay for extra which i have many times. Theyre also very weak with the toppings often hiding the lack of what they put on under the little bit of cheese. Expect the pie to be very red looking from the scarce amount of cheese w little toppings even if you ask and pay for DOUBLE. Not once. MANY times. I hate to give them a bad review because i like the owner. But it is what it is. Their dinners are the same... Expect small portions that could be far better so easily. Wanna charge more? Do it. But give the people what they pay for. Brunellos has more potential than any other nearby place yet it suffers probably because of poor careless kitchen employees. The girls are very friendly and helpful but the food could and should be far superior to what we're being given. I know MANY people within a few blocks of this place thatve all echoed these exact thoughts. Noone wants to hurt the nice owner so they just go elsewhere myself included. But maybe this review could help spark the much needed changes so that i can remove it someday and feel good about this place again. A few years ago it was sooo much better. What...

This is a great local pizzeria!! I order from them about once a month and have never been disappointed. Their crust is delicious... and many people under estimate the importance of the crust ..... my personal favorite is white pizza with black olives and they always nail it. The Knots and Calamari are both exceptional. I have ordered the Italian entrees from time to time and all are well done offerings. Salads are fresh and so are the toppings that they use. Employees are nice and friendly and the restaurant is very clean. You would think these things are a given but sadly not all local businesses think to pay attention to them. You wont be disappointed...

Honestly, we switched to here when the place closer to our house got ridiculously expensive. The staff in here is always friendly and has a smile for you. The food is delicious, fresh and hot! Also well-priced and won’t break the bank. I’m sorry we didn’t come here sooner!

One time, after I ordered and paid, I asked if while it was being made I had a second to run next door to Carvel (I wanted to pick up a surprise for hubby after a bad day) and the young man said “Absolutely, I’ll have it boxed and ready for you.” Sure enough, came back a few minutes later and there it was. This is our new...