Gino's of Lindenhurst Pizzeria & Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Babylon

Had our first square/ Sicilian pie W/ sausage here! I have nothing but good things to say about the quality of the pie. Plenty of toppings cover the pie. Will definitely be trying other things on the menu in the very near future. Just wanna say I do have a pizza place 2 blocks from me & I rather order your pie & wait for a better quality pizza by a long shot! The second reason I don't order pizza near me anymore is simply because the owner told me at 12:30 in the afternoon that there's nobody there to make a pizza right now come back in 15 minutes, thought that was totally absurd at 12:30 in the afternoon for a pizza shop when they're primary thing is making pizza. Mind you on any given week I would spend anywhere from $30 to $40 @ at a time. This is not the thing you tell the regular customer. ATT: CRITIQUING PUBLIC! For those of you who critique a pizzeria or any other business for not getting what you want on time, or one time is also not fair for you to give one star to any business! You need to give to benefit of the doubt in a business and go back there a second or third time before you critique any business and give it one star. Don't be so fast to judge unless you know what it's like to be judged by your family, friends when you cook and you're insulted by being...

Stopped in with my parents to grab a quick lunch. We figured we grab a quick slice but after 1 glance at the menu we knew we were ordering more than pizza. We started with some fried artichokes and baked clams. Both dishes came in the most delicious sauces that we happily sopped up with the bread they served when we sat. Next we got an order of the Calamari Siciliana which were perfectly cooked calamari topped with broccoli rabe, cherry peppers and a sprinkle of Gorgonzola. My taste buds were dancing, it’s the type of dish you go back for.

After the apps we weren’t really hungry for heavy pizza so the Thai chicken pizzette served on the the thinnest and crispiest crust was perfect!! We ended up taking most of the delicious pasta home after a few bites we were so full. The pesto rosso was delicious with chicken and a flavor sauce of red sauce mixed with pesto.

So much more than pizza. Gino’s is a true...

I've been ordering from Gino's of Lindenhurst since they opened. Sometimes 2-3 times per week over the years. When we have parties over the Summer we usually will order 5 or 6 pies.

However, lately their food has been disappointing. When you get a slice or two to go there are always charred black pieces of god knows what on the bottom of the slice that ruins the taste. This hasn't been a one time thing. It has happened the last 4 or 5 times I've gone here. They need to deep clean their ovens. Last week I ordered two specialty slices to go and I got severely sick multiple times in the middle of the night. It wasn't pretty. This used to be my favorite pizzeria is this part of Suffolk and their vodka slice has been one of my all time favorite slices, but unfortunately I think I need to look elsewhere...