Piazzetta of East Farmingdale — Restaurant in Town of Babylon

PLEASE dont judge this place by the fake 4-5 negative reviews left in a row by a customer and his friends, who also tried to bash this place on a Farmingdale Facebook group because his antipasta or something he ordered was messed up. After his negative review, he had his friends with zero more important things to do in their lives leave fake reviews. They have nothing better to do than trying to hurt a successful business. Fine you are not happy..go leave your review and move in. Dont get your friends to then follow with more fake reviews. I have lived in Farmingdale for 6 years and have always been treated respectfully here and have become friendly with workers as well (Juan is the best!). The food has always been on point and delicious. As many of my friends and neighbors say, you cant go wrong with Piazzetta. Some people complain about price I see here but it is not much different than any other pizza place around or any other take out for that matter. Everything in this world is more expensive now. You also get what you pay for, but hey you can't please everyone. Anyway, great pizza...grandma, sicilian, and regular are all favorites of mine. Their penne alla vodka is also a family favorite in my house. I have tried all the pizza places in town and this is my favorite by far! Keep up the great...

Ive been ordering from here for years it’s definitely going down hill . Now I always order big orders $100 minimum 2 times ago they made a wrong pizza for us not the end of the world as we ate it , the last time we ordered they forgot an item that was over $20 . I understand things happen but our time was limited and we couldn’t wait to have the item delivered 45 minutes later so they credited my account . Tonight we ordered and i had them repeat my order which they read back perfectly. When I picked up i asked are you sure everything was in there they said yes . Sure enough i get home and it’s missing an item . I call tell me i never ordered it ? And if i want it I need to pay , well that doesnt sit well with me . I then say “you know what use my credit and give me back the remaining balance as I don’t think i will be using you anymore.” They tell me I cant have the difference back in cash only credit. So they took my cash to pay for an item I didnt receive and refused to give me my money back for that item , imagine that. I was a good customer never spent less then $100 at a time here because im Usually ordering for multiple families at a time and this is how I get treated. I can assure you all these families wont be ordering...

My wife saw the Chicken Caesar pizza on a Long Island ad so we took a ride from Queens and I have to tell you it was well worth the drive. Delicious!!!! We then had the Margarita pizza and again worth every penny. To finish it all off we had the Tartufo for dessert. Mouth watering. The presentation was excellent and the chocolate was the best tasting chocolate I’ve had in a very long time. Staff is super friendly (from the guys behind the counter to the waitresses). Plenty of parking and super clean. Kudos to the entire staff and especially Jerry who answered all my questions without any hesitation. Thank you all and we will be returning for the entrees on our next visit. Highly recommended.

Had dinner last night and it was excellent. I had the Black Sea Bass which was breaded with panko bread crumbs, white rice and spicy mango salad. My wife had the Chicken Primavera with grilled vegetables. Besides the portions being large, the taste on both were superb. Hats off to the chef and my waiter Juan Carlo who is friendly, knows all the dishes, and treats customers like family. I also want to thank Jerry again for his hospitality. If you are in the area or not (like me) Piazetta is the place to eat....