PELLEGRINO'S PIZZA — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

The good: The staff is friendly, very hard working people, the service is very fast and they are attentive. It's located in the Shoreham Plaza for easy access to other stores and shopping needs. They do local delivery. Owned and operated for many decades by the same gentleman I believe.

The bad: With regard to the food, the pizza, it is the worst pizza. Many of my colleagues have said the same thing. Their regular slices, are atrocious, excessive oil running off, the cheese and sauce is awful, the sauce and cheese just fall off the slice, the crust is weak and just a sloppy mess when you hold it up, it falls apart and flops over. The margherita slices, which should be a one of a kind slice, it's the same thing, it's awful. Instead of tasting fresh and made with love, it tastes like something that was made from a high school lunchroom. The garlic knots, oh my…….they are terrible too, no flavor, it tasted like it was just dipped in canola oil. It also tasted like they just used garlic powder. Not only it had no flavor, no traditional toppings, it had zero texture, barley cooked, disgusting. So how can these three simple popular food items be so horrendous? Their bathroom has been out of service too for a while. Washing your hands it’s not an options I suppose, unless you want to eat with the hand sanitizer gel prior, that’s wonderful. The Wading River pizza place next to King Kullen has way better pizza, also Rocky Point has great pizza too. And at those other locations you can order alcoholic beverages since they have a nice dining room area. I’d rather drive the extra 10 minutes to get better food. If your in High School, maybe you won’t mind the Pellegrino’s options, or traveling further distances is an issue. But other than that, it’s...

⚡Lisa - UPDATE- 10 ⭐ The box, the pizza, the box, the pizza, THE BOX, THE PIZZA!!! OMG 😮They got a new Holiday Box! Bravo! The Sicilian pizza slice😮OMG! Heaven in my mouth! You know, That's how it's Done! Pelligrino's Pelligrino's ✨ The Best!👍👍👍 - Lisa Lichelle ✨ ⚡ Lisa - Update! Pellegrino's has set the new standard in excellence. I just had the best Chicken Parmesan Pizza Slice on the East Coast. Yeah yeah, I have had pizza up and down the East Coast from Canada, NY to FL. It was the best pizza ever. I had to pull over, look at it and take pictures of it 👀 What! Mannnn Bravo to The Pizza Makers there. WOW! They have set the new 5 Star standard. I might take some other places stars back one, after That 👀 lol. frfr 👀 And Awesome service too. I got my slice while they were finishing up my Delivery order. Bravo, Bravo and Bravissimo 10 Star ⭐ Lisa Lichelle ✨ ⚡ Lisa - Ahhh Pellegrino's ! Great Service. The friendliest staff. Their customers love them. Quick, efficient, always hot, right off the press. Way to...

I wanted to like it as the people working there are nice but wow this is the worst pizza I’ve had in a long time.

The garlic knot is very obviously garlic powder soaked in some canola oil. Tastes like soggy bread.

The pizza is all cheese with no hint of a sauce on one slice… the other is way too much sauce and the sauce tastes like ragu pizza sauce. Very sweet but very cheap tasting. Hard to pinpoint but it’s not good.

Dough is uneven on each slice so not properly kneaded. This is impressively bad as not one thing is right, I feel bad for the owner as he’s a nice guy but this is horrible pizza. I’d genuinely prefer dominos. The garlic knot was a sin by itself as well. Don’t even sell them if this is what you give.

On top of it all, it isn’t cheap. It’s 4$ a slice, most likely because he has no customers so he needs offset by charging people way more than it’s worth on who dares walk in.

What a shame - great location and pass...