The BlackSheep at Miller Place — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

Absolutely phenomenal! The sandwiches are hands down the best I have had anywhere on Long Island. So delicious I cannot wait to try them all! We tried the fried pesto chicken sandwich and the steak sandwich and both loved our meals. Everything was on point and perfect - the ciabetta bread and arugula being so fresh, the balsamic glaze was a nice touch and there was just the right amount of melted goat cheese. The steak was cooked perfectly at medium rare and the onions were a delicious compliment. We did not have room for dessert but that did not stop us from grabbing the chocolate flourless cake to go - definitely worth it ! You have to check this place out - you will not be disappointed! Has that local charm too - it almost reminds me of The Beef from...

Omg the food was amazing! We stopped in for lunch and hadn’t yet been. I got the Loren’s flying chicken sandwich and a salad instead of fries. The house dressing was a lemon vinaigrette that was out of this world! And nice mix of crisp lettuce, and everything was fresh! And nice switch using the chicken thigh instead of a breast cutlet- it was so good! My husband had Braise Your Belly” pork belly with veggies and lemongrass. This was not our usual style of eating, but wow- it is now! The owners were so nice and made everything fresh to order....

So, we tried Black Sheep. No bueno. The first issue was the price. $72 for a family of 4. We ordered 2 kids meal hamburgers and each burger was charged $7.00 for a small order of fries. Burgers were outstanding. The fries were awful. $7.00 is crazy. The salad with steak was well worth it. The chicken fingers were hard as a rock and were left uneaten. Again, another $7.00 for a side of fries. Upsurd. For $72 we can go to panera AND get pizza. ...