The Pepperoni Grill Pizzeria & Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

Pepperoni Grill is DELICIOUS. We have been ordering pepp grill for years. Our kids only eat plain pizza so if me and the Mrs want some specialty pizza pepperoni grill is the way to go because they make all of their pies available in personal pie size. Our family of 5 will usually order 3 or 4 small pies in order to have VARIETY, which I love. We have had a great experience with all the dishes, Im surprised to see someone complained about the artichoke and caper salad because I order that exact salad all the time, we just had it again last night and it was DELICIOUS as usual, I urge you to try it! Another thing that makes people grill UNIQUE is the SAUCE! I don’t know what they put in that sauce but it is so darn good! They also DELIVER so you don’t have to get rolled by door dash for delivery, last night the owner’s father actually delivered our food , he was such a nice man, the quick talk that we had just made me feel good about the food I was bringing in to my family....

So I’m new to the area and had been frequenting Pepperoni Grill over the last few weeks. The food was great and prices weren’t bad at all. I was even referring friends to try them too. That all changed today though however.

I usually keep it simple and go with the different pizza slices. But today I wanted to treat myself a bit and decided to order the Shrimp Francese. Hands down one of the worst dishs I’ve ever had in my life.

First they served with penne instead linquini even though the description clearly states linquini which makes world of a difference. It was also drowned in sauce so much it honestly was like pretty much a soup. The shrimp? 4 total pieces in entire dish. Zero taste and was cold! The kicker though? I got that with small 20oz soda and total was $33. WHAT?!?! Keep in mind there literally small takeout spot not even fancy italian restaurant. The whole expierence completely turned me off. Never again will...

I’ve had pepperoni grill a few times, each time trying something different, and it always hits. You don’t expect a place with this much on the menu to make everything well, but so far I’ve yet to get a miss. I will say, today was my first time having a wrap and the flavor was 10/10 but it missed a few points on execution. It had pears in it which are huge and could afford to be sliced, the wrap wasn’t cut, and it was barely holding together and wasn’t wrapped tight. However, the chicken in it was delicious.. thin, not chewy at all, and grilled to perfection with a nice char. The dressing was also delicious. And the garlic knots are always a 10/10, soft but chewy, not greasy with a perfect garlic flavor. I’ve also had their Italian wedding soup which is sooo good, and the penne vodka which was delicious and well priced. Def...