Sammys
Sammys things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Description
Relaxed restaurant offering an upscale surf 'n' turf menu with steak & lobster, plus harbor views.
attractions: Montauk Yacht Club, Montauk County Park, Sun 'N' Sound, The Sunset Montauk, Sunset Beach, Gin Beach, restaurants: Gosman's Restaurant, Inlet Seafood Restaurant, Clam and Chowder House at Salivar's Dock, The Dock Bar & Grill, Westlake Fish House, Hideaway Montauk, Seaside House Bar, Kenny's Castaways, Goldberg's, Star Island Grill
Ratings
Description
Relaxed restaurant offering an upscale surf 'n' turf menu with steak & lobster, plus harbor views.
Posts
Let me start by saying your food is excellent we love it .... We were hear a couple years ago and I absolutely loved the place..But with that said you need help with your staff The older lady with the short blonde hair and glasses...She is not a professional waitress at all by any means.. they need to say Hi my name is so-and-so would you like a drink Or what would you like to drink ..Then when we got the drinks I got 3 coffees for 1050 and they didn't ask if we need a refill anything If you're spending that much for a single cup of coffee and sodas I think you should have refills I understand if it's not free refills but then the waitress should say would you like a glass of water or something... Your kids menu doesn't have a dessert I've never seen one kid's menu that don't have a dessert.. And then they had a Father's Day special on the back of the menue and I said O can I get the Father's Day special and she said no that's for tomorrow .. It had no date and it had nothing stating that it wasn't for the day that it was in the menu The 1st time I was here I felt welcomed this time I felt like I was being rushed and that I was infringing on the waitresses time to herself And bugging her This time that we went There was very upsetting not Comfortable at all
Donald LesnakDonald Lesnak
30
We stopped at Sammys on the go, their food truck across from Gosman's Clam bar waterside. There was a long line of locals. The only one working was an older lady on the inside managing it all and super busy. I was very grossed out by her receiving money and then immediately turning around and touching food with her bare hands without washing them. Not so much as even an antibacterial pump. The menu was scarce with high priced items ranging from fish to fries. $21.99 for a "lobster roll" which was more like a lobster or seafood salad, I'm not entirely sure it wasn't a mix of seafood/imitation seafood, or just shredded lobster. Not my favorite. The mahi tacos were reasonably priced at $4.95 a piece, but came from a freezer. They came in a decent tasting corn tortilla adorned with cabbage, shredded cheddar, pico mix, a lime, and an unidentifiable orange cream sauce. They were okay. The mozzarella cheese sticks were $6.95, your average everyday frozen to fried sticks with pre packaged marinara. Overall I was very unimpressed with their food safety practice and overpriced mediocre average old school fair food truck taste....
Mandilynne FMandilynne F
10
We are headed to the seafood festival and were reminded of our wonderful experience last May during the annual music festival. The drinks and beer taps are tops, but we were hungry too! Unquestionably, the best fish and chips ever! Need I say more? Obviously, after partaking of the seafood fare at the fest, we will have to revisit Sammy’s on our next trek to Montauk. This place is a standout in the area. Updated August 2023. Place is empty at 530pm for dinner! Table of 6. On porch. The fish and chips were below par. Halibut fresh. Disappointed. Better options from here on in.
Mack VismusicMack Vismusic
20
This review is for Sammy’s to Go (the food truck). Amazing place to get reasonably priced delicious takeout breakfast or lunch. And… you can sit on the beach and eat it! I can only speak about the fish tacos (I ordered 2 and they were delicious), and the fried flounder sandwich came on a toasted potato bun with delicious tartar sauce on the side. Perfect breading. Great quick lunch with a view! :)
Amanda Grace Petrocelli McLeanAmanda Grace Petrocelli McLean
00
Hey, it's Ginger from Gilligan's Island. Our hostess name is Ginger and she looks like Ginger from Gilligan's Island. She is beautiful. We had a great time and the food was so delicious. I can't believe I finished my whole plate, it was that good. Hats off to the Chef de Cuisine. The place was recommended by someone who was fishing near The Lighthouse.
Mahbuba ShahrinMahbuba Shahrin
00
Hey, it's Ginger from Gilligan's Island. Our hostess name is Ginger and she looks like Ginger from Gilligan's Island. She is beautiful. We had a great time and the food was so delicious. I can't believe I finished my whole plate, it was that good. Hats off to the Chef de Cuisine. The place was recommended by someone who was fishing near The Lighthouse.
Mahbuba ShahrinMahbuba Shahrin
00
Nearby Attractions Of Sammys
Montauk Yacht Club
Montauk County Park
Sun 'N' Sound
The Sunset Montauk
Sunset Beach
Gin Beach

Montauk Yacht Club
4.2
(231)Click for details

Montauk County Park
4.8
(71)Click for details

Sun 'N' Sound
4.4
(53)Click for details

The Sunset Montauk
4.7
(46)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Sammys
Gosman's Restaurant
Inlet Seafood Restaurant
Clam and Chowder House at Salivar's Dock
The Dock Bar & Grill
Westlake Fish House
Hideaway Montauk
Seaside House Bar
Kenny's Castaways
Goldberg's
Star Island Grill

Gosman's Restaurant
4.1
(754)$$
Click for details

Inlet Seafood Restaurant
4.3
(458)$$
Click for details

Clam and Chowder House at Salivar's Dock
4.1
(223)$$
Click for details

The Dock Bar & Grill
4.5
(196)Click for details
Reviews
- Unable to get your location