Bar-Eat-O — Restaurant in Town of Geneseo

I've been here several times, both for food and drinks. When they first opened, I was super excited to try it. It was fine. With time, I hoped, it would get better. Sadly, this wasn't true.

The food has always been 'meh' at best. Personally, I like Chipotle's food better. There are more options here, but it seems like everything sits out for long periods of time and the taste reflects that.

I've had good experiences at the bar during the day. However, this was years ago. It was never that busy. I don't know if this place gets wild at night with the college kids.

My most recent visit, there was no bartender. That meant we couldn't get drinks. There were people sitting at the bar just waiting and not one staff member acknowledged them. There was also a sign posted: "one drink per patron." Pretty bad for a Saturday at 3PM.

Geneseo needed a taco place on Main St. Too bad this one...

Awful service at bar. We walked in past two employees sitting at end of bar, said hi to them and than sat at far end of bar. Neither one came down to serve us after 10 mins we needed to get up, walked to them and asked them to serve us. And when we needed a second drink, needed to walk to them and ask to be served again.. And it wasn't busy, we were the only ones in bar. The music was blasting, we could hardly hear our conversation sitting next to each other...asked the server 3 times to please lower the music, finally after 3rd time she did, but only a little...still blasting music for only us in the bar when we requested to lower it 3 times. We left, went to another bar in town. Won't be back. Good food,...

We stopped in for a first visit at lunchtime on a very quiet Saturday. The place is much bigger inside than it looks from the road and I would imagine it’s a great college bar in the late evening. I wasn’t very hungry, so ordered just a couple tacos. My initial request was for the Chorizo, but was told that it wasn’t available at that time, so I chose the Baja Fish taco. They were just okay. I suppose it’s unfair to compare them to the fresh fish in a Florida restaurant as this is not remotely in the same class of place. Bar-Eat-O is a college town bar with some just okay food. Probably not worth the great reviews as others have posted. Not really recommended, unless it’s midnight on a Saturday and you’re 20...