MR SOFTEE STORE / HAMPTONS SOFT ICE CREAM INC — Restaurant in Town of Islip

My wife convinced me to get it I knew was a bad idea. I ordered the ice cream sandwich. Six scoops of ice cream or four big scoops of ice cream in between two waffles. After you choose your ice cream, they dip it into one of three sauces a chocolate sauce, a cherry sauce or a blue raspberry sauce and then they dip it in sprinkles. It is definitely big enough to share between two or more people in my opinion and I wish I didn’t eat all six scoops of ice cream and two waffles but I did because I paid $10 for an ice cream burger. I’ll only get it again if I share, but I definitely did not regret my decision. It’s super unique and really fun experience to have. Our group left so full as we all chowed down on our ice...

What’s not to like about Mr. Softee? This is childhood nostalgia in a cup (or cone) but with a storefront that stays open late enough to fuel your late night cravings.

The Choco Taco? Ohhh … MASSIVE, peanut-crusted, and worth every single bite. If you don’t order one, we can’t be friends. They’ve got all sorts of specialty options, but why fix what isn’t broken?

Line looks scary sometimes but it moves quick don’t worry. This place isn’t trying to be bougie gelato or artisanal rolled ice cream it’s Mr. Softee. Classic, messy, and exactly what your inner kid signed...

Service is great. Food? Eh. Personally I’m not sure if it’s the atmosphere of chasing down the ice cream truck or whatever magic goes on in the truck to make the ice cream taste good-you’re better off chasing down a Mr. Softee than going here. Or just go to another ice cream shop. The ice cream isn’t bad -just not notably good. I got a sundae and cherry dipped cone for me and people and we agreed a carton of Breyers is better. Also idk if it was a one fluke but my cherry dipped didn’t have that Mr.Softee...