Napper Tandy’s — Restaurant in Town of Islip

First time visited Napper Tandy's in Bayshore the bartender had made the best irish coffee i ever had. I think the key was that he used heavy cream. Since then i have returned and I feel like the other bartenders here might not be coffee drinkers because the irish coffee that is made is ok. Its irish coffee but its not the same as that first visit. The food is mediocre. On my visit tonight i order a weekly special of 3 shredded chicken tacos because its a Tuesday night. The quality of these tacos is understandable if there is only one or two cooks total in the kitchen considering it is somewhat busy for a Tuesday night but still, its as if they just took grilled chicken and threw some tomatoes and avocados on topand sent it out of the kitchen. If it was $6 or $7 id so ok its expected they wouldnt be anything to great but for $14 dollars i expected more. They were bland and felt like they were thrown together in a hurry. Honestly the only reason i have come back here is for the irish coffee that i had on my first visit whicu so far has no been replicated. Which is upsetting because in my mind that was the only real draw to this place. Its a fine pub but theres nothing that makes it stand out especially amongst the other bars and eateries in bayshore. If they can replicate the irish coffee they had mad on my first visit as their standard for irish coffees it would be the draw of this location. Unfortunately the food is nothing to rave about and the drinks are your standard bar drinks. But they are crowded on a Tuesday night so i might just be picky and my opinion probably doesn't matter but im still entitled to it and i hope that at the very least they can step up their irish coffee game. As far as the description vs what was served, i see no grated cheese and the so called pico de gallo is tomatoes and a few small pieces...

Forget every assumption you have about an Irish Pub before visiting Napper Tandy’s in Bay Shore…

My wife and I eat in Bay Shore frequently. We have seen Napper Tandy’s multiple times but never went in thinking it would be a loud and obnoxious dive bar. Boy were we ever wrong!

We visited tonight (3/8/23) and sat at a table in a nook area opposite the bar. Our server was Ryan - who was also the bartender. Ryan greeted us warmly, we spoke about the dining selections in Bay Shore and other restaurants we’ve visited. Ryan quickly brought our drinks and gave us time to look at the menu (after offering some suggestions). He came back awhile later to take our orders and was again helpful in deciding from among the available specials.

My wife had the lettuce wraps with chicken. At Ryan’s recommendation, I started with the potato leek soup and then had the Irish Bacon and Cabbage… leaner and tastier than Corned Beef (my other choice).

Our food came out quickly and was prepared excellently. All of our selections were hot, cooked to perfection and tasty.

Ryan checked in on us several times but was never annoying. He was engaging and friendly.

We dine out once or twice a week. Rest assured that Napper Tandy’s in Bay Shore will be someplace we’ll visit again (soon).

Thanks to Ryan and the entire staff at Napper Tandy’s for welcoming us into your restaurant and for an outstanding...

I had the most amazing bridal shower on Saturday. Napper’s is the definition of a hidden gem. The price and affordability of this place is insane. The room is absolutely stunning. To say I was obsessed with the exposed brick, the fireplace, and the turquoise statement bar is the biggest understatement. Shannon was an absolute godsend when it came to planning the party. She was also there during the entire event to lend a helping hand and make sure everything ran smoothly. The food was amazing. When you think of a bar, you don’t think about stellar buffet food but my god, I can’t tell you how many people raved over the buffet selections. The bar was fully stocked with 10 beer options, wines, and a whole champagne bar which had 8 different juices and fruit! The staff was so helpful, kind, and efficient. The guys stayed downstairs at the bar to celebrate my fiance's birthday and they were blown away with the bar service and food. He said the shrimp tacos were delicious…even better than Rhums! I am SO happy we went with Napper’s for the venue. It was an...