Pizzaiolo Gourmet Eatery — Restaurant in Town of Islip

I love this pizzeria! They're always polite and service is very quick! They're food is phenomenal and I've never had anything bad to say, however , I did just order yesterday for delivery(1 pie and soda) I was very stunned and confused when the kid delivery driver(first time I've ever encountered him)came, instead of delivering to my door, he called my phone and told me that my food was here and he was outside and to come to the driveway to get my food!?! I then thought he was at the wrong door. so I replied,"oh my door is the one with the wreath hanging". His reply to me again was,"I'm at the end of the driveway can you come outside your food is here!". ...?? So Im confused like waiting with my door opened puzzled like, what? is he coming to my door? Or?. So then i went all the way outside( mind u with no shoes on or jacket, and its freezing) like really?? Very unacceptable and rude !! The whole point of ordering delivery service is so I can have my food delivered right to my door, especially that I'm paying for a delivery fee, like It blows my mind that he thought it was okay to even do that!! That is your job and you get paid to receive the delivery orders and take the food to the customers doorstep. Not to think it's ok to call the customer and tell them to come outside to get their order esp with no shoes or jacket! Ive never had a delivery driver call me and do that! I didnt even want to hand him a tip because, tipping a delivery driver is optional, your already being charged a delivery fee, and you tip someone because they executed excellent service, or go above and beyond to satisfy you or just because you want to. He gets paid to get the orders and bring to the address to the door! and for him to call me and have me come to get my own food is just ridiculous and just plain lazy,! I've never had that happen! The kids today are just lazy and spoiled and dont know what the true meaning of hard work means! Bambinas should definitely talk to him and explain what delivery means because hes jeopardizing they're business by...

🎉 Huge shoutout to Pizzaiolo and John Campanella for making our daughter’s college graduation party this past Saturday an unforgettable event! They handled all the catering, and WOW…the food was absolutely incredible! I only wish I had taken more pictures to show just how amazing everything looked.

Let me just say… the marinated skirt steak and shrimp scampi were out of this world. Every dish was bursting with flavor, from the meatballs, chicken parmigiana, and penne alla vodka to the chicken francese, pasta with broccoli, house and Caesar salads, garlic knots, bread, and of course, the cannolis for dessert. Everything came with extra sauces and dressings, and the entire setup was done for us, stress-free and beautifully arranged.

What really impressed us was the attention to detail. They went above and beyond to accommodate our guests with food allergies, including lactose intolerance and celiac disease. They prepared separate, generously portioned dishes that were safe, delicious, and appreciated more than I can say.

Guests are still raving about the food days later and honestly, I wish we had more leftovers to enjoy today!

If you’re looking for high-quality, professional catering with unforgettable flavor and impeccable service, Pizzaiolo is the way to go. Thank you, John and team, for making our celebration so...

Never wrote a review before but it's time. We've ordered from this pizzeria multiple times. If I guessed 20 times and atleast 19 times there was a problem with the food. It's been from giving us the wrong order then replacing it with undercooked pizza to this last order which we had it delivered. We ordered a large cheese pie with extra cheese and 6 garlic knots. When we received the pizza the cheese was on one side of the box and the garlic knots were burnt to the point they were not edible. I returned the pizza and the response was that I was the one who caused the issue with the pizza from the way I picked it up. I had to remind them that they delivered it. I just took a full refund left the pizza and garlic knots there and went somewhere else. I can say after this I will not be returning to...