Lenny's Steakhouse — Restaurant in Town of Mamaroneck

Went there for my wife’s birthday same as last year. Went there specifically for 2 lb lobster. I called for reservation and told them it was my wife’s birthday and I wanted to reserve a 2 lb female lobster (has the roe which my wife loves) Got there and was told we could have small table in main dining room or larger table downstairs. We chose larger table as we were going to have steak lobster and sides. Disappointed with room downstairs as it was a drab party room in basement with bar and no WiFi. Stayed because we wanted larger table. Ordered dirty martinis which were good. Told waiter about reserving female lobster and he had no idea what I was talking about. Ordered wedge salad, the lobster, porterhouse, creamed spinach and home fries. Salad was small but dressing good. Lobster and steak came. The lobster was not a female and closer to pound and half than 2 lbs with tiny claws and was not female. Waiter and cook had no idea what roe was and that’s how you can tell it’s female. Steak was small and over cooked but tasty. We kept both as my wife had her heart set on lobster. The creamed spinach was good but the home fries was tasteless plate of a few potatoes. The waiter brought us over 2 complimentary glasses of wine to make up for our obvious disappointment but we would have rather had another martini or dessert or coffee which we ordered. Waiter brought over coconut cream cake and cappuccino which were both good but no mention of my wife’s birthday! All of this cost $300 which was no way worth it. Place has gone down so far in a year. Can’t see us...

THIS IS A MUST DINE!!!!! It has actually become my favorite Steakhouse! Lenny's is more then a Steakhouse the menu has one great dish after the other, not just steak. The service, waitstaff, and chef is TOP NOTCH! Right along with every dish we have ordered. We have dined here once a week for the past month. We look forward to it, the simplest dish escarole & beans, = PERFECTION! We order it everytime. So besides the best escarole beans we have tried & our suggestions are a LIST long: Mohawk Long Bone Ribeye for 2 - cook perfectly, melted in your mouth Chicken Martini - , another delicious dish White Dover Sole with Caper and White Wine, deboned tableside - lovely choice Seaford Tower for 2 - you have to order this, so good!!!!! *Crispy Skin Wild Salmon - we left nothing on the plate, absolutely delicious *Beef Capaccio - just yum *Tuna Tartar - it really is just one great dish after the other... My boyfriend and I decided we are going to try the entire menu and order something different every dine, Lenny's is doing it right! The dining area is always full, the drinks are equally as good they have great top shelf choices. I can not say enough great things about Lenny's, I could have dinner there every night

One of the best steakhouses around, better than Morton's, if you ask me. I've been here a couple times now for friends birthdays, as it's a great place to celebrate.

I've had the Filet Mignon, and of course, their Tomahawk Ribeye, both are incredible. The sear they get on their steaks is perfect; how they manage to get such a crisp crust, yet keep the inside perfectly medium rare is beyond me. The sides are great too, especially the duck fat home fries and candied bacon. Jesus Christ, those duck fat home fries are insanely delicious. Crisp on the outside, airy and fluffy on the inside, they're some of the best potatoes I've ever had. We ordered the fresh mozzarella to start with, and it had slices of the biggest beefsteak tomatoes I've ever seen. I'm not usually a fan of beefsteaks, but these were fresh and delicious. I had the chocolate mousse cake for dessert and, surprise, that was delicious too. Even their drink selection is impressive, I was able to order myself Lagavulin, a not so common single malt scotch.

To top it all off, the service is also top notch. The wait staff is attentive, but not intrusive, always a quick wave away from the table, and never once rushed us. Very friendly and accommodating.

If you're a lower Westchester or Bronx resident, I highly recommend you stop by here for a great...