Pumpernickel's Deli, Restaurant and Catering — Restaurant in Town of New Hartford

There's a good reason this place has been around as long as it has...EXCELLENT food, AMAZING servers and a clean, nice place! Phil is an amazing guy, and his pride shows in the quality of his food, the staff that represent him, and it's no wonder he's been in business for decades!

Went with my wife for dinner tonight and as always, Pumpernickel's did not disappoint. We don't come out enough. Our server was attentive and jovial, and the food is fresh...almost everything homemade. Oh...and get dessert...trust me...

So, if you are reading this, you probably have never been, because if you had eaten here before, you'd already know how good this place is and wouldn't need to read my review. So go, now......

Had a very bad experience although the waitress was very nice and polite I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich with mushrooms onions and peppers on a grilled brioche bun what I got was a fried chicken patty on Italian bread it was burnt the chicken tasted like fish the side of fries was uncooked and the coleslaw tasted like it was from a jar called to explain my situation after getting back to the job site to eat lunch then found out the woman I spoke to on the phone told me I didn't order my lunch from there and it didn't come from there obviously I won't be going back obviously very dissatisfied would not recommend this place to anyone for any reason wish I could post a...

Tonight my wife and I ordered fish fry's to go. I place our order at 4:45 pm with a pick up time of 6:45 pm. As I arrived and went inside I could see it was very busy. I gave my name and after waiting patiently for over a half an hour the owner (Phil) came to me and apologized for the long wait and offered a certificate on our next purchase. I told him thank you and understand the situation. Phil, the wait was definitely worth it and would do it over again. One of the best fish fry's I had in a while! My wife and I come at least once a month and will continue to support your...