Luigi's Pizzeria of Mineola — Restaurant in Town of North Hempstead

Sharing bad reviews brings me no joy, but here we go: Ordered 2 pies. 1 regular, 1 vegan, sautéed broccoli (w/garlic and oil), & garlic knots. Grubhub delivery stated between 6-6:10, so we chose this reasonable option. As time went on, the delivery time increased. No problem-Friday's can be crazy. It was posted for some time that the order was on its way, but a call to the restaurant confirmed it just left at 6:30 ("our delivery is backed up") Maybe being honest about that with customers in the first place would have been helpful. We could have chosen another place instead of being misled. The food arrived around 6:45. Both pies- ice cold. The regular pie was so floppy that it folded onto itself in the box. As if it were dropped. The broccoli was not cooked enough and was in a 1/2 inch of liquid, leaving it w/o taste. The garlic knots were huge, a weird consistency, leaked oil all over when bitten. This has never happened before from here. I dont like complaining, but I called the restaurant to report the regular pizza as it could not be salvaged. I felt rushed and like an inconvenience for it. they sent a replacement some time later. Nobody wanted it at this point. Out of aggravation-we went to bed without dinner after paying a decent amount. I have informed grubhub, who are only refunding the pizza. Unfortunately, we will not be returning to eat here. Busy nights are no excuse for paying customers to receive food like this. Very disappointing....

I am not sure how some of these reviews are giving Luigi's anything below 5 stars. I have been coming here since I was a kid and I have nothing but great things to say about them. In fact, Luigi's is probably my most favorite pizzeria in the area.

Starting off with the menu, this restaurant has one of the widest selection of slices I have seen. They have so many specialty options to choose from but my favorites are the spinach artichoke slice and the vodka slice. Recently, I have noticed that they are rotating new options such as a spicy vodka burrata slice. They also cater to anyone with dietary restrictions by making gluten free and vegan slices as well. If you are in the mood for other Italian dishes, they have a variety of pastas, pizzas, heroes, and desserts to choose from. I have tried their eggplant parm hero and it is a solid lunch option.

The restaurant is spacious, clean, set with modern decor. There is ample seating and different table sizes to account for different group sizes. The restaurant is located in a small strip mall with a huge parking lot so parking is not an issue.

The staff has always been nice to me and I notice that they hire a lot of young kids in the area which shows that they support our community. I hope nothing but the best for this restaurant and I would love to see it grow even more in the...

What a Hidden Gem! Discovered this Amazing Pizza Restaurant after making a wrong turn and I am SO glad i did.

Great vibe, GREAT pizza , super clean and modern he had and so many different food choices.

If pizza could have a candy store this would be it!

The owner was super friendly and genuine! They have a reward system with every purchase and I can’t wait to come back with the kids! It will easily become our new Italian family restaurant!

MUST try everything! Nice parking lot and super nice staff.

NYC pizzerias for the most part can be “not so friendly” to 1st time customers! Tend to stick to locals. They are Usually friendly after your a known repeat customer BUT not here.

Owner treated me with respect and kindness and even threw in some garlic knots on the house and i felt welcomed into his restaurant!

definitely a great experience and i highly...